Merlin Wiki
Merlin Wiki
"The last man standing takes the prize. Let the tournament begin."


Rules Current fight Support fight Decide fight Results Archives Ladder

Merlin Wiki Arena's revival![]

Welcome visitors and editors, this is the Merlin Arena! Each week, four of the most requested fights from the Merlin universe were pit against each other, in a fight that was determined by the votes of registered users.


The Merlin Arena used to be moderated by MorganaForEver. However it's revived by Merlin the Immortal, and it's he who moderates the Merlin Arena, as you read.

The Rules[]

This is a popularity contest. You may vote for your favorite or whom you think would win in a fight between the two combatants that are chosen to fight. Failure to comply with these rules will likely result in a scale from your vote being removed up to being banned from participating in future fights.

  • While justifying your choice, you have to type whom you want to win in bold.
  • Each user votes only once. An anonymous cannot abuse this either, as the vote record is assigned to your IP address.
  • Anonymous users have just as much right to vote as registered users.
  • To vote, check one bubble under the character of your choice, then click the 'Vote!' button. You are able to change thy vote, but we advise against it.
  • Justifying your choice is essential too, in order to have a clearer result, so please justify your choice below the poll and also type your signature (~~~~)

Current fights[]

It is in combat that we learn a knight's true nature, whether he is indeed a warrior or a coward. The tournament begins!
I'd be honored to introduce the participators of this time!

FIGHT #55 a : The Dochraid vs. The Troll
Troll uther.jpg

If you don't see the poll, click here
Justify purple box.png
Justify purple box.png
FIGHT #55 b : Morgana Pendragon vs. Kilgharrah

If you don't see the poll, click here
Justify purple box.png
Justify purple box.png


Click "Expand"

Fight A Justification[]

  • The Dochraid is a creature of earth she is immortal (she ca be killed by a sword forged in dragon's breath), so  Merlin the Immortal  ToA Wiki  Massage Wall  Contribs  19:33,8/22/2021 

Fight B Justification[]

  • Kilgharrah won't die by pity magics!  Merlin the Immortal  ToA Wiki  Massage Wall  Contribs  19:33,8/22/2021 
  • The mere fact that Catrina was able to infiltrate the Royal Court and kiss Uther... I would say she won with her goal ~~~~

Suggested fights[]

To add one, click here.

Click "Expand"
*Morgana vs Arthur
  • Dochraid vs Jonas
  • Agravaine vs the Troll
  • Gwaine vs Morgana
  • Aithusa vs Morgana
  • Cockatrice vs Wilddeoren
  • Alvarr vs Tristan
  • Arthur vs Aithusa
  • Gorlois vs Uther
  • Gaius vs Tristan De Bois
  • The Dorocha vs The knights of Medhir
  • Valiant vs Agravaine
  • Agravaine vs Halig
  • Morgana vs Tristan
  • Isolde vs Morgana
  • Mithian vs Morgana
  • The Cailleach vs The Dorocha
  • Sophia vs Aulfric
  • Sophia vs Morgana
  • The Vilia vs The Dorocha
  • Arthur vs Agravaine
  • Princess Mithian vs Queen Annis
  • Lancelot vs Helios
  • Arthur vs Uther
  • Lancelot vs Mordred
  • Gwaine vs Mary Collins
  • Sir Cador vs Helios' servant
  • Uther vs Merlin
  • King Bayard vs King Cenred
  • Merlin vs Gaius
  • Gwaine vs Percival
  • Agravaine vs Gwen
  • Mordred vs Leon
  • Mordred vs Nimueh
  • Goblin vs Troll
  • Freya vs Morgana
  • Merlin vs Mordred
  • Mordred vs Kilgharrah
  • Nimueh vs Freya
  • Gwaine vs Lancelot
  • Freya vs Mordred
  • Jonas vs Troll
  • Goblin vs Jonas
  • Merlin vs Kilgharrah
  • Nimueh vs Mordred
  • Hengist vs Halig
  • Elyan vs Agravaine
  • Freya vs Sophia
  • Lamia vs Grunhilda
  • Sir Leon vs Agravaine
  • Goblin vs Manticore
  • Lamia vs Questing Beast
  • Dorocha vs Questing Beast
  • Griffin vs Bastet
  • Merlin vs George
  • Uther vs Mordred
  • Agravaine vs Morgana
  • Uther vs Morgause
  • Bayard vs Tristan
  • Arthur vs Gwen
  • Southrons vs Cenred's army
  • Cornelius Sigan vs Morgana
  • Aredian vs Halig
  • Serket vs Bastet
  • Nimueh vs Arthur
  • Gwaine vs Gwen
  • Gwen vs Vivian
  • Wyvern vs Gilli
  • Vivian vs Mithian
  • Elena vs Gwen
  • Merlin vs Morgana
  • Gwaine vs Arthur
  • "Merlin vs Arthur"
  • Serket vs Wilddeoren
  • Morgana vs Mordred
  • Morgana vs Gaius
  • Elyan vs Lancelot
  • Lancelot vs Arthur
  • King Rodor vs King Uther
  • Cenred vs Uther
  • Catrina vs Gaius
  • The Euchdag vs Freya
  • Morgana vs The Cailleach
  • Gwaine vs Mordred
  • Uther vs Morgana
  • Freya vs Agravaine
  • Gilli vs freya
  • Balinor vs Julius Borden
  • Gaius vs Sidhe Elder
  • Gwen vs Morgana
  • Sefa vs Gwen
  • Morgana vs Mordered
  • The Knights of the Round Table vs Dragoon the Great
  • Gaius vs The Goblin
  • Arthur vs Lancelot
  • Arthur vs Elyan
  • Queen Mab vs Merlin
  • Merlin vs Albin
  • Sarrum vs Merlin
  • Ruadan vs Arthur
  • Arthur vs Helios
  • Merlin vs Morgana
  • Elyan vs Morgana
  • Gwaine vs Lamia
  • Leon vs Lamia
  • Lamia vs Gwen
  • Mordred vs The Disir
  • Aithusa vs The Great Dragon
  • Dragoon the Great vs The Dochraid'
  • Gwen vs Arthur
  • Gaius vs The Dochraid
  • Morgana vs the Dolma 
  • Aithusa vs Kilgharrah
  • Kara vs Eira
  • Kara vs Mordred
  • Mordred vs Merlin
  • Aithusa vs Sarrum
  • Albin vs Daegal
  • Sefa vs Daegal
  • Sefa vs Eira
  • Merlin vs Elyan
  • Morgana vs Beroun
  • Alator vs Aithusa
  • Mordred vs Aithusa
  • Beroun vs Mordred
  • Mithian vs Odin
  • The Gleeman vs Lamia
  • Lamia vs Mithian
  • Rodor vs Gwaine
  • Eira vs Gwaine
  • Guinevere vs Eira
  • Sefa vs Ruadan
  • Kilgarrrah vs The Dochraid
  • Elyan vs Tristan
  • The Questing Beast vs The Griffin
  • Nimueh vs Morgause
  • King Olaf vs Cenred
  • The Witchfinder vs Edwin
  • Edwin vs The Griffin
  • Tauren vs Edwin
  • Mordred vs Gaius

Arena Results

Fight #54 b
Morgana Pendragon 3
Arthur Pendragon 5

Fight #54 a
Merlin 8
Uther Pendragon 0 Such a shame

Fight #53 d
Freya 3
Aithusa 4

Fight #53 c
Isolde 1
Mithian 5

Fight #53 b
Dochraid 2
Morgana 3

Fight #53 a
Mordred 2
Lancelot 6

Fight #52 d
Freya 3
Morgause 8

Fight #52 c
Questing Beast 1
Dorocha 8

Fight #52 b
Knights of Camelot 10
Saxons 1

Fight #52 a
The Euchdag 4
Morgana 6

Fight #51
Nimueh 144
Atorloppe 32

Fight #50
Morgause 115
Guinevere 68

Fight #49
Tristan de Bois 135
Myror 51

Fight #48
Caerleon 66
Ragnor 25

Fight #47b
Anhora 170
Grunhilda 23

Fight #47a
Elyan 214
Ruadan 47

Fight #46b
Balinor 211
Aithusa 50

Fight #46a
Percival 204
Leon 38

Fight #45c
Percival 229
Leon 191

Fight #45b
Lancelot 311
Gaius 258

Fight #45a
Arthur 390
Gwen 323

Fight #44c
Sefa 304
Eira 41

Fight #44b
Ari 169
Beroun 41

Fight #44a
Freya 499
Kara 51

Fight #43c
Julius Borden 348
Valiant 141

Fight #43b
Alator 486
Finna 216

Fight #43a
Merlin 1037
Agravaine 30

Fight #42c
Daegal 217
Gilli 84

Fight #42b
Saxons 182
Southrons 36

Fight #42a
Queen Annis 240
Ygraine 67

Fight #41c
Dochraid 246
Jonas 47

Fight #41b
Sarrum 179
Hengist 54

Fight #41a
Gwaine 400
Mordred 191

Fight #40c
Osgar 130
Tauren 128

Fight #40b
Rodor 133
Bayard 67

Fight #40a
Pellinore 135
Owain 99

Fight #39c
Elyan 277
Tom 201

Fight #39b
Mab 250
Euchdag 230

Fight #39a
Derian 232
Odin 209

Fight #38b
Fomorroh 180
Nathair 90

Fight #38a
Merlin 506
George 54

Fight #37b
The Cailleach 169
Dochraid 47

Fight #37a
The Troll 198
Grunhilda 57

Fight #36b
Gaius 275
Alice 25

Fight #36a
Aredian 160
The Gleeman 41

Fight #35b
Helios 68
Cenred 49

Fight #35a
Iseldir 119
Taliesin 68

Fight #34b
Alvarr 157
Ruadan 145

Fight #34a
Alator 240
Aglain 125

Fight #33b
Tristan 263
Julius Borden 51

Fight #33a
Elena 358
Vivian 123

Fight #32b
Gilli 248
Edwin Muirden 136

Fight #32a
Morgana 454
Morgause 157

Fight #31
Merlin 403
Percival 67

Fight #30
Mordred 187
Cornelius Sigan 75

Fight #29
Elyan 205
Tristan de Bois 108

Fight #28
Aithusa 295
Sidhe Elder 108

Fight #27
Mordred 247
Uther 94

Fight #26
Guinevere 182
Annis 61

Fight #25
Lancelot 146
Leon 116

Fight #24
Morgause 133
Freya 132

Fight #23
Bayard 111
Odin 111

Fight #22
Gwaine 160
Agravaine 9

Fight #21b
Alvarr 82
Tauren 12

Fight #21a
Cenred 61
Caerleon 55

Fight #20
Percival 111
Valiant 9

Fight #19
Morgana 104
Guinevere 44

Fight #18
Freya 137
Sophia 22

Fight #17
Merlin 156
Mordred 37

Fight #16
Gaius 77
Fisher King 18

Fight #15
Nimueh 74
Morgause 53

Fight #14
Knights of Camelot 45
Knights of Medhir 27

Fight #13
Percival 49
Elyan 25

Fight #12
Alvarr 100
Lancelot 77

Fight #11
Mithian 49
Guinevere 45

Fight #10
Isolde 28
Tristan 18

Fight #9
Dragon 78
Wyvern 7

Fight #8
Morgana 83
Nimueh 59

Fight #7
Leon 63
Helios 25

Fight #6
Kilgharrah 105
Aithusa 30

Fight #5
Uther 104
Agravaine 23

Fight #4
Gwaine 72
Arthur 66

Fight #3
Arthur 52
Morgana 46

Fight #2
Arthur 72
Mordred 58

Fight #1
Merlin 130
Morgana 46


Arena Archives

Fight: #54 B
Victor: Arthur (5 votes)

Loser: Morgana (3 votes)

Note: No magic is involved.


Fight: #54 A
Victor: Merlin (8 votes)

Loser: Uther (0 votes)


Fight: #53 A
Victor: Lancelot (6 votes)

Loser: Mordred (2 votes)


Fight: #53 B
Victor: Morgana (3 votes)

Loser: Dochraid (2 votes)


  • The Ancient Dochraid is a creature of earth, it's hard to choose but I think she's more powerful & She's a troll, by the way! Merlin the Immortal  ToA Wiki  Massage Wall  Contribs  10:47,8/9/2021 

Fight: #53 C
Victor: Mithian (5 votes)

Loser: Isolde (1 votes)


  • Isolde was a warrior while Princess Mithian isn't, but she's cleverer than Isolde, another hard choose. Merlin the Immortal  ToA Wiki  Massage Wall  Contribs  10:47,8/9/2021 

Fight: #53 D
Victor: Aithusa (4 votes)

Loser: Freya (3 votes)


Fight: #52 A
Victor: Morgana (6 votes)

Loser: TheEuchdag (4 votes)


Fight: #52 B
Victor: Knights of Camelot (10 votes)

Loser: Saxons (1 vote)


  • Knights of the Camelot are eminent for being most noble and most powerful army in the 5 kingdoms! Merlin the Immortal  ToA Wiki  Massage Wall  Contribs  13:01,8/2/2021 

Fight: #52 C Victor: Dorocha (8 votes)

Loser: Questing Beast (1 vote)


  • Even Merlin's magic was useless against the Dorocha, also they are immortal while the beasts aren't, no mortal has ever survived their touch but Merlin! Merlin the Immortal  ToA Wiki  Massage Wall  Contribs  13:01,8/2/2021 

Fight: #52 D Victor: Morgause (8 votes)

Loser: Freya (3 votes)


  • Freya in beast form can beat Morgause easily; she could beat even Arthur but it seems she did want to harm nobody Merlin the Immortal  ToA Wiki  Massage Wall  Contribs  13:01,8/2/2021 
  • I think that Morgause could whip up some sort of army pretty easily; and even though they haven't been successful in the past, she would be able to overpower Freya, even in cat form. Magic right? I think Morgause's magical skills will give her an advantage.

Fight #51: Atorloppe vs Nimueh

Victor: Nimueh (144 votes)

Loser: Atorloppe (32 votes)


  • Atorloppe is powerful! I vote for her! GLLC.png Gwaine signature2.pngEquals.pngCenred signature1.png 10:38, February 17, 2013 (UTC)
  • Nimeua is a High Priestess. Even though she isnt as powerfull as Atorloppe, she has more pain and sorrow in her background to keep her going. :) Good luck to both, and may the best sorceress win!
  • It's a tricky decision, as Nimueh has more depth, but Atorloppe is one of the Disir- she would already how know the fight would go.. and her way. She has the power to bring people back to life (like Mordred), and has poisonous weapons. Plus wasn't she handpicked by the Gods at birth? It would have to be
  • Nimiuh though is used to fighting on her own, but Atorloppe is used to having her sisters fight with her. On her own she maybe disadvantaged Daniel's signing.pngink=User:Dryuuu 03:11, February 20, 2013 (UTC)Dryuuu

Fight #50: Morgause vs Guinevere

Victor: Morgause (115 votes)

Loser: Guinevere (68 votes)


  • MORGAUSE IS A WITCH! NUFF SAID! GLLC.png Gwaine signature2.pngEquals.pngCenred signature1.png 10:06, February 17, 2013 (UTC)
  • True Gwen was pretty handy in a fight but Morgause was a High Priestess of the Old Religion! Theres no contest! Character wise I prefer Gwen though
  • Morgause is a witch so yea. Gwen would be NO match
  • Are you kidding?  Gwen would be a puddle of goo in 3 seconds.  Maybe less.
  • Morgause was a High Priestess of the Old Religion, I seriously doubt Guinevere is good enough with a sword to beat her.
  • Gwen could kill Morgause with kindness, but seeing as Morgause is a High Priestess, I think the outcome is obvious... May the Force and odds be with you in your favour! T.a14 (talk) 21:11, February 14, 2013 (UTC)
  • Morgause was a High Priestess of the Old Religion, and like her sister Morgana was extremely powerful, if she can beat Arthur in a duel she certainly can kick a servants arse !!!!

Fight #49: Myror vs Tristan de Bois

Victor: Tristan de Bois (135 votes)

Loser: Myror (51 votes)


  • Tristan de Bois... is undead! Myror... is mortal! Not a hard choice... Tristan de Bois! GLLC.png Gwaine signature2.pngEquals.pngCenred signature1.png 00:47, February 2, 2013 (UTC)
  • Myror is an assassin. Translation- a coward. But then again look at how he took out Odin's men. So maybe not. Ok, Tristan is undead. That's settled. Tristan de Bois! Daniel's signing.pngink=User:Dryuuu 15:43, February 2, 2013 (UTC)Dryuuu
  • Tristan de Bois is undead and can only be killed with a certain sword, which Myror doesn't have! Definitely Tristan de Bois!
  • Tristan can only be killed by Exaliber and Myror can't wield it!!! Tristan de Bois!
  • Undead aside, Tristan is still a better fighter. Myror is an assassin. Assassins tend to kill people who are not expecting a fight. If the world was their battlefield and Tristan was not undead, I may say Myror, but in a basic fight, I'd have to give this one to Tristan.
  • "Tristan fought for a cause, to avenge his sister. Myror is just a thug."

Fight #48: Caerleon vs Ragnor

Victor: Anhora (66 votes)

Loser: Grunhilda (25 votes)


  • Caerleon is a king, Ruadan is a bandit. It would be seemingly impossible for a king to lose against a bandit, so go Caerleon! GLLC.png Gwaine signature2.pngEquals.pngCenred signature1.png 05:46, January 27, 2013 (UTC)
  • Caerleon ROCKS!!! Even though he's dead. But he has a really brave Queen at his side! Superman-Logo-Signature-QaYYum.png

~TomWelling~ Superman-Logo-Signature-QaYYum.png 05:55, January 27, 2013 (UTC)

Fight #47b: Grunhilda vs Anhora

Victor: Anhora (170 votes)

Loser: Grunhilda (23 votes)


  • I vote for Grunhilda!!!! The Pixie that must return!!!! Lol jokes. GLLC.png Gwaine signature2.pngEquals.pngCenred signature1.png 00:00, January 19, 2013 (UTC)
  • Grunhilda could be beaten with a broom alone! So not her! Haha! Daniel's signing.pngink=User:Dryuuu 02:06, January 26, 2013 (UTC)Dryuuu

Fight #47a: Ruadan vs Elyan

Victor: Elyan (214 votes)

Loser: Ruadan (47 votes)


  • Hmmm Ruadan has magic. Elyan doesn't. But I don't know who would win!? Duh... GLLC.png Gwaine signature2.pngEquals.pngCenred signature1.png 00:00, January 19, 2013 (UTC)
  • Ruadan, if he rematched Elyan, would still win due to his magic and ninja skills. He'd also be enraged at Elyan, who pretty much killed him. But that was a sneaky attack. One on one, Ruadan could win, he took on Arthur and won after all. Daniel's signing.pngink=User:Dryuuu 02:04, January 26, 2013 (UTC)Dryuuu

Fight #46b: Balinor vs Aithusa

Victor: Balinor (211 votes)

Loser: Aithusa (50 votes)


  • Well seeing as Balinor is a DRAGONLORD it would be impossible for Aithusa to defeat him without Balinor to command him/her (they never explained what gender Aithusa was). So my vote is for BALINOR!!! GLLC.png Gwaine signature2.pngEquals.pngCenred signature1.png 14:11, January 12, 2013 (UTC)

Fight #46a: Mithian vs Sefa

Victor: Mithian (204 votes)

Loser: Sefa (38 votes)


  • Mithian seems like she would win because she seems stronger than Sefa

  • Without hesitation I vote for MITHIAN. Sefa didn't even bother to return for revenge on Gwen. -_- GLLC.png Gwaine signature2.pngEquals.pngCenred signature1.png 14:09, January 12, 2013 (UTC)
  • I vote for Mithian! S207.237.232.133 11:22, January 17, 2013 (UTC)he's far more interesting and better character :) AriadniASB 00:18, January 13, 2013 (UTC)
  • --Mithian's a princess, and it wasn't at all uncommon for them to be trained in weapons. We see some of her ability with at least a crossbow in the Hunter's Heart, a weapon that takes skill and strength to wield, particularly from horseback. Also because I love Mithian.

Fight #45c: Leon vs Percival

Victor: Percival (229 votes)

Loser: Leon (191 votes)


  • Without hesitation I vote for LEON! I am now officially a shipper of Gweon and I cannot go against Leon, sorry Percy. GLLC.png Gwaine signature2.pngEquals.pngCenred signature1.png 13:25, January 5, 2013 (UTC)
  • PERCY!!!!!!! REMEMBER, ALWAYS SHIP PERWAINE IN MEMORY OF GWAINE, RIP GWAINE, so vote for his other half Percival! Gwaine artist.png 15:02, January 5, 2013 (UTC) and i also need to update my signature...
  • Of course Percival! He is stronger than Leon!!! Mariaforever (talk) 16:31, January 5, 2013 (UTC)
  • Leon has experience, Percival can only win if he has to push rocks! TheLastLastDragonlord (talk) 18:09, January 5, 2013 (UTC)
  • I voted Leon cause he is AWESOMEEE
  • I vote for Percival, not because I like him more than Leon (Actually, I like them both), but because I think he is stronger than Leon. AriadniASB (talk) 22:00, January 11, 2013 (UTC)

Fight #45b: Lancelot vs Gaius

Victor: Lancelot (311 votes)

Loser: Gaius (258 votes)


  • Of course I vote for Lancelot! One of my favourite Knights. R.I.P! GLLC.png Gwaine signature2.pngEquals.pngCenred signature1.png 13:25, January 5, 2013 (UTC)
  • Even though Lancelot is one of my fav. knights I have to go with Giaus. Giaus just kicks ass! TheLastLastDragonlord (talk) 18:07, January 5, 2013 (UTC)

Fight #45a: Guinevere vs Arthur

Victor: Arthur (390 votes)

Loser: Guinevere (323 votes)


  • Arthur is none other than a complete imbecile. I vote Gwen, she got annoying at times but at least there was something inside her head. GLLC.png Gwaine signature2.pngEquals.pngCenred signature1.png 13:25, January 5, 2013 (UTC)

Fight #44c: Eira vs Sefa

Victor: Sefa (304 votes)

Loser: Eira (41 votes)


  • I vote for Eira as she appears to have a sluttish behavior in which seems to get herself what she wants... Sefa didn't even bother the return (actually, the producers didn't bother the return her, but hey! That's the real world). GLLC.png Gwaine signature2.pngEquals.pngCenred signature1.png 01:14, December 29, 2012 (UTC)
  • I like both of them. Eira was...cooler, but Sefa was less evil. - -ғιre αɴd ѕнαdowѕ
  • Sefa! Her father Ruadan was a sorcerer and would have taught Sefa a lot more. Sefa lasted longer. Sefa did not spy out of her own self-interest like Eira who just wanted cash- she did it for her father. Sefa all the way. I am only sad she did not reappear... Daniel's signing.pngink=User:Dryuuu 08:21, January 1, 2013 (UTC)Dryuuu
  • I vote Sefa, she lasted longer and was more innocent and i loveed her from the first episode :D
  • I vote for Sefa, because she was more of a compelling spy since she was doing it out of the love for her father.  Eira on the other hand was a meaningless character -- she spied to fatten her pockets.  There was no honor or any purpose for her motive.  Sweetnatured/Nakisa

Fight #44b: Ari vs Beroun

Victor: Ari (169 votes)

Loser: Beroun (41 votes)


  • Beroun! I really pity Ari, but I don't think the guy can put up a fight...MorganaMorgana Pendragon.pngForever22:09,12/28/2012
  • Poor Ari, looks so sad in that picture. He has magic, so I vote for him! GLLC.png Gwaine signature2.pngEquals.pngCenred signature1.png 15:04, December 29, 2012 (UTC)
  • As long as Ari has his magic (maybe he could go to the Crystal Caves himself) he would flog Beroun. But without it, he doesn't seem to be anything! Daniel's signing.pngink=User:Dryuuu 08:19, January 1, 2013 (UTC)Dryuuu

Fight #44a: Kara vs Freya

Victor: Freya (499 votes)

Loser: Kara (51 votes)


  • Kara!!! Freya is nice and all, but she despises fighting, so she would probably lose...Besides, we don't know if she can do much without the Bastet curse. I still love her though :) MorganaMorgana Pendragon.pngForever22:10,12/28/2012
  • FREYA! Kara just goes around stabbing people willy-nilly; Freya is better at defending herself within reason, like when she defended herself against the attacker whose mother cursed her. Kara might win in a fight, but only if she cheated and took a cheap-shot, like she did when she tried to stab/kill Arthur after telling him she meant no harm. -Adelina Le Morte March
  • Of course I voted for Freya! After all, she is the Lady of the Lake... whereas Kara is just one of those 'more talk, less do' type of people. Go Freya! GLLC.png Gwaine signature2.pngEquals.pngCenred signature1.png 01:29, December 29, 2012 (UTC)
  • Freya all the wayShe has the most wonderful character and can also change into a bastet. With Merlin present, she'd definetly win. Leonardomerlinfan (talk) 11:18, December 29, 2012 (UTC)
  • Freya without a thought. She has a good heart and does what is right, except when she transforms (which was NOT HER CHOICE). By giving Merlin Excalibur she helped defend against the undead army and protect Arthur. Kara, on the other hand, is selfish and vengeful and will not listen to reason even when Arthur showed her mercy twice. ~Ela
  • Freya. Kara probably knows no combat spells. Freya's been on the run for so long and has probably trained herself. She's a fighter, with a good heart. Kara is just a fanatic. She didn't even use magic to fight Arthur, the one she loathed the most, she just tried to stab him. Freya can also turn into a giant flying cat-like beast and chew Kara to pieces! Daniel's signing.pngink=User:Dryuuu 08:17, January 1, 2013 (UTC)Dryuuu
  • I liked Freya because she was an endearing character.    Although she  turned into a beast by night she felt quite remorseful the next day, because she knew she had hurt others. Her character was tragic, not only because she was cursed she had lost those she loved so early in life.  Also she cared so much for Merlin that she was willing to let him go, before she would see him hurt. Freya also redeemed herself, when she told Merlin to retrieve  Excalibur during Camelots darkest hour.    Kara on the other hand was vengeful and filled with hate.  She refuse to forgive Arthur for the sins of his father.  Even after Arthur offered to let her live she she still remained bitter and hateful until her death.  Her refusal to get passed her anger caused deaths for not only Arthur, but for Mordred  the man she loved.  I felt her character was just a catalyst to get the outcome and final ending of the series.  Unfortunately, it was not a happy ending -- it was ending that cancelled out any hope of magic returning to Camelot. Sweetnatured/Nakisa

Fight #43c: Julius Borden vs Valiant

Victor: Julius Borden (348 votes)

Loser: Valiant (141 votes)


  • Valiant is quite a charismatic villain, while Borden is a lowly rapscallion.
  • I choose Julius Borden! He was a better and smarter villain. MorganaMorgana Pendragon.pngForever00:18,12/22/2012
  • I vote for Borden, Will Mellor was a terrible actor... No offence. GLLC.png Gwaine signature2.pngEquals.pngCenred signature1.png 04:46, December 22, 2012 (UTC)
  • Valiant, he is charismatic, has authority, and is trained. Borden is power-hungry too but doesn't even know how to hatch a dragon egg and has spent, what, 20 years looking for it? Serious. But other than that Borden was very determined and good at it, but my decision is Valiant! (And seriously, this was the only decent arena battle this week, it's a competition not an obvious YES OR NO question). Daniel's signing.pngink=User:Dryuuu 09:42, December 23, 2012 (UTC)Dryuuu
  • Valliant is great. The other one is really pathetic! Agnes Flether

Fight #43b: Finna vs Alator

Victor: Alator (486 votes)

Loser: Finna (216 votes)


  • I choose Alator! He is Finna's teacher after all. MorganaMorgana Pendragon.pngForever00:18,12/22/2012
  • I pick Finna. Alator acted cowardly. GLLC.png Gwaine signature2.pngEquals.pngCenred signature1.png 04:46, December 22, 2012 (UTC)
  • I don't know why. I just like Alator more. Agnes Flethcer

Fight #43a: Merlin vs Agravaine

Victor: Merlin (1037 votes)

Loser: Agravaine (30 votes)


  • Well lets see. Merlin=Powerful warlock, Agrivane=Annoying Uncle. Merlin=Alive. Agrivane=Dead. Merlin=Has a whole cult/fandom around him. Agrivane=Needed to fill a plot for one of the series. oh and of course Merlin=GOOD Agrivane=Bad at trying to be EVIL!!   Emrys!
  • Merlin. I don't think I even need to justify. GLLC.png Gwaine signature2.pngEquals.pngCenred signature1.png 04:46, December 22, 2012 (UTC)
  • Seeing how Merlin killed him with ease at the end of Season 4, I think this vote should be no surprise.
  • AGRAPAIN (Agravain) must be broken and sent to a not very nice place MorganaEmyrs Signature.pngMorganaEmyrs Devil thingy signature.pngMorganaEmyrs Signature logo - Copy.png 12:24, December 22, 2012 (UTC)
  • AGRAVAINE, YOU CAN DO THIS!!! MorganaMorgana Pendragon.pngForever22:41,12/22/2012
  • Are you kidding there is NO comparison at all , Merlin hands down magical being- enough said
  • Merlin is by far the best- Emyrs all the way! 
  • What kind of arena battle is this? Daniel's signing.pngink=User:Dryuuu 09:41, December 23, 2012 (UTC)Dryuuu
  • Merlin killed Agravaine once, didn't he? He can do it again. Scarletwind"I'm checking for woodworm" 00:04, December 25, 2012 (UTC)
  • What?... TheLastLastDragonlord (talk) 16:05, December 26, 2012 (UTC)
  • Was this battle made just to see how badly agravaine would get owned? 800 to 20, is that like a record? Phoenixon (talk) 20:58, December 26, 2012 (UTC)
  • Merlin. The show isn't called Agravaine, after all. (:
  • Although he gets on my nerves lots of times, Merlin is still better than Agravaine. Agnes Fletcher
  • i vote merlin. agravane it is fat 0090j (talk) 12:47, December 28, 2012 (UTC)

Fight #42b: Daegal vs Gilli

Victor: Daegal (217 votes)

Loser: Gilli (84 votes)


  • I vote for Gilli! Daegal is just a wimpy little coward, Gilli isn't afraid of anything! GLLC.png Gwaine signature2.pngEquals.pngCenred signature1.png 04:26, December 15, 2012 (UTC)
  • Definitely Gilli! He is brave and strong. MorganaMorgana Pendragon.pngForever12:29,12/15/2012

Fight #42a: Annis vs Ygraine

Victor: Annis (240 votes)

Loser: Ygraine (67 votes)


  • Annis is strong, powerful, independant. Ygraine is lovely, but in the end, she died as a mother, as the cause for a war. Annis's husband died, she said no to Morgana and turned the Kingdom around to ally with Camelot. I love them both, but Annis gets my vote.
  • Annis is a big enough person to forgive and forge friendship with Arthur. Ygraine has not proven herself to be as noble as Annis in this regard. She is always portrayed as vengeful toward Uther and distant toward Arthur (even though she is dead).
  • Ygraine. SHE HAS TO APPEAR MORE! MorganaMorgana Pendragon.pngForever12:29,12/15/2012

Fight #42b: Southrons vs Saxons

Victor: Saxons (182 votes)

Loser: Southrons (36 votes)


  • I pick the Saxons because of their armour! GLLC.png Gwaine signature2.pngEquals.pngCenred signature1.png 00:58, December 15, 2012 (UTC)
  • Saxons! Because of their strength. The southrons lost to opponents like Guinevere, who hit them to the head with a sword's hilt! MorganaMorgana Pendragon.pngForever12:29,12/15/2012

Fight #41c: Jonas vs Dochraid

Victor: Dochraid (246 votes)

Loser: Jonas (47 votes)


  • I vote for Jonas. Love his tail! :P GLLC.png Gwaine signature2.pngEquals.pngCenred signature1.png 01:35, December 8, 2012 (UTC)
  • The Dochraid. She is the earth itself! (I also had a scary dream with her in it last night) Daniel's signing.pngink=User:Dryuuu 03:07, December 8, 2012 (UTC)Dryuuu
  • The Dochraid. She's powerful. She knows a lot. She gets my vote. WitchOfCamelot , 23:24, December 14, 2012 (UTC)

Fight #41a: Mordred vs Gwaine

Victor: Gwaine (400 votes)

Loser: Mordred (191 votes)


  • I vote for Gwaine! Mordred is mediocre with magic(he accepted he doesn't stand a chance againist Morgana) and mediocre with the sword(still a newbie knight) so a skillful knight like Gwaine can handle him. MorganaMorgana Pendragon.pngForever19:44,12/7/2012
  • I think you all know who i'm going to say!!!!!!!!!!!! GWAINE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!love ya eoin <3 i bet gerda will say mordred though. and for this, i'm going to use my old signature: Gwaine artist.png 21:32, December 7, 2012 (UTC)
  • I am going to vote for Mordred! He has magic!!!!!!!!!! But I like Gwaine tons better though. GLLC.png Gwaine signature2.pngEquals.pngCenred signature1.png 01:35, December 8, 2012 (UTC)
  • Definitely Mordred. I don't think he is mediocre with magic as Morganaforever said- in the Witch's Quickening he was apparently able to wield a crystal that Morgana was not able to wield back then. He was also able to strike without chanting a spell and knock out a High Priestess in one blow. He could easily do that to Gwaine. He also fares well against King Arthur. As for sword combat against Gwaine, I think Gwaine would just win. So in magic, yes, obviously because Gwaine has none, and in sword, probably not. All in all, Mordred is more powerful. (With a greater destiny, too) Daniel's signing.pngink=User:Dryuuu 03:06, December 8, 2012 (UTC)Dryuuu
  • MORDRED! He should have used magic when the Knights of Round Table was bullying him in "The Disir". --

Superman-Logo-Signature-QaYYum.png ~TomWelling~ Superman-Logo-Signature-QaYYum.png

01:33, December 8, 2012 (UTC)
  • Modred. I do feel that stragetically and with a sword Gaine is better but Modred has magic and is pretty powerful, so that concludes it! TheLastLastDragonlord (talk) 23:14, December 8, 2012 (UTC)
  • I am choosing MORDRED!! I will always support my knight in shining armour!! Besides, he has magic and is a great swordfighter: Gwaine would never win this one. And Mordred is a way more interesting character for me than Gwaine is! Siggy w.gif 18:50, December 8, 2012 (UTC)
  • Mordred all the way! As much as I adore Gwaine, he will never win a fight against the man who will one day kill Arthur.Chawk1993 (talk) 09:37, December 10, 2012 (UTC)
  • Mordred is Awesome! I voted for him but there both good!
  • you have got to vote for mordred as he is the only night of camalot to stop morganas plans and knock her out and even auther cannot believe that he defeted morgana

Fight #41b: Hengist vs Sarrum

Victor: Sarrum (179 votes)

Loser: Hengist (54 votes)


  • Not sure who I hate less....I guess Hengist! MorganaMorgana Pendragon.pngForever19:44,12/7/2012
  • I think Sarrum would win because he'd get someone else to assassinate Hengist! -Chloe- (talk) 19:48, December 7, 2012 (UTC)
  • I vote for Hengist. Sarrum had Albin to do his dirty work for him whereas Hengist actually fought the Wilddeoren! GLLC.png Gwaine signature2.pngEquals.pngCenred signature1.png 01:35, December 8, 2012 (UTC)
  • Sarrum- Uther himself feared Sarrum. Hengist is fat and he just sits there all day. Sarrum trained men who could beat Arthur (who could beat Uther). He also had the nerve to capture Morgana and a dragon! So definitely Sarrum. Daniel's signing.pngink=User:Dryuuu 03:11, December 8, 2012 (UTC)Dryuuu

Fight #40a: Pellinore vs Owain

Victor: Pellinore (135 votes)

Loser: Owain (99 votes)


  • Sir Owain it is! Watching the battle againist Tristan de Bois again, it looks like he did a better job than Pellinore. MorganaMorgana Pendragon.pngForever17:04,11/30/2012
  • Although they both would have slain Tristan de Bois if it weren't for his immortality as a Wraith, I am going to vote for Pellinore. When he slashed him with his sword it was clear to all of Camelot as oppose to when Owain did it, only Merlin saw. But oh I miss the old Series 1 days of Merlin. :( GLLC.png Gwaine signature2.pngEquals.pngCenred signature1.png 21:30, November 30, 2012 (UTC)
  • Owain fights like a real warrior!! Love it! 

Superman-Logo-Signature-QaYYum.png ~TomWelling~ Superman-Logo-Signature-QaYYum.png

04:28, December 1, 2012 (UTC)

  • Pellinore looks more badass! TheLastLastDragonlord (talk) 11:51, December 1, 2012 (UTC)
  • Owain was the first to challenge the Black Knight. Proves that he is more braver. J8in (talk) 21:44, December 1, 2012 (UTC)
  • Owain is braver and has proven more. He's got more development. He's a warrior and proved his honour. I can only make a judgment for him! Shame we can't get Arthur with us to decide the real winner, though!Daniel's signing.pngink=User:Dryuuu 10:25, December 2, 2012 (UTC)Dryuuu

  • Definitely Sir Pellinore. He did get a clean strike at Tristan. If Tristan was a human he would have been dead. Helloise29 (talk) 16:20, December 5, 2012 (UTC)Helloise

Fight #40b: Bayard vs Rodor

Victor: Rodor (133 votes)

Loser: Bayard (67 votes)


  • Rodor! He actually fought by Arthur's side despite being an old man, but from what we know Bayard has others do his dirty work. MorganaMorgana Pendragon.pngForever17:04,11/30/2012
  • I am going to go with Bayard. He looks slightly younger and since this is not a magical duel where old people dominate, Rodor cannot win as he looks to be slightly older than Bayard. Sorry Rodor but Bayard it is! GLLC.png Gwaine signature2.pngEquals.pngCenred signature1.png 21:47, November 30, 2012 (UTC)
  • King Rodor's the best!! He has a pretty daughter and he stands up to Odin!! 

Superman-Logo-Signature-QaYYum.png ~TomWelling~ Superman-Logo-Signature-QaYYum.png

09:45, December 1, 2012 (UTC)

  • Of course I vote for Bayard! He needs to appear again however he probably don't. J8in (talk) 21:46, December 1, 2012 (UTC)
  • Rodor, he is old but a good fighter! Daniel's signing.pngink=User:Dryuuu 10:26, December 2, 2012 (UTC)Dryuuu

Fight #39c: Osgar vs Tauren

Victor: Osgar (130 votes)

Loser: Tauren (128 votes)


  • Gotta go with Osgar. I liked the actor a lot better, the actor of Tauren was rather hopeless to be honest. Aside from this I cannot determine them regarding a fight so Osgar it is!  Gwaine signature2.pngEquals.pngCenred signature1.png 21:47, November 30, 2012 (UTC)
  • Tauren sucks!!!! Osgar is greater that Tauren! Tauren is just sick and wrong!!!! Osgar is smarter and braver.  

Superman-Logo-Signature-QaYYum.png ~TomWelling~ Superman-Logo-Signature-QaYYum.png

09:44, December 1, 2012 (UTC)

  • Osgar!!! Best guest character ever! A villain with actual depth...MorganaMorgana Pendragon.pngForever19:45,12/1/2012
  • Nice fight description by the way, as the circle of fate begins to close I vote for Osgar. He looks like one of my other favorite character. Alvarr. J8in (talk) 21:47, December 1, 2012 (UTC)
  • Osgar. He has purpose and more direct combat magic. Tauren relies on his puny little crystal and he's a coward. Daniel's signing.pngink=User:Dryuuu 10:25, December 2, 2012 (UTC)Dryuuu
  • I gotta go with Osgar, He has so much depth,i mean he could have killed arthur and his knights with a swipe of his finger, even after elyan and gwaine attacked and stabbed hi,. he didn't kill them, just simply flicked them out of his way. he is so honorable any loyal.


Fight #39a: Odin vs Derian

Victor: Derian (232 votes)

Loser: Odin (209 votes)


  • I vote for Derian!!! The man's a beast! Odin is just...meh! MorganaMorgana Pendragon.pngForever19:29,11/23/2012
  • I vote for Derian because he didn't have as many votes and because Odin tried to kill Arthur twice of his own free will whereas Derian only tried to kill Arthur once and that was under orders from someone else.~Merlin:)~
  • Well after seeing Odin nearly defeat a fully strengthened Arthur in Another's Sorrow and seeing Arthur almost manage to defeat Derian with an enchanted sword in His Father's Son, I believe Odin, as a king, would be able to find a way to defeat Derian. GLLC.png Gwaine signature2.pngEquals.pngCenred signature1.png 00:48, November 24, 2012 (UTC)
  • Derian! Love the big dude! Hate Odin! Always wants Arthur!??

Superman-Logo-Signature-QaYYum.png ~TomWelling~ Superman-Logo-Signature-QaYYum.png

04:34, November 24, 2012 (UTC)

  • Logic states Derian. Arthur pretty easily overcame Odin whereas he was equal to Derian, only beating him through the help of Merlin's magic
  • I have faith in Odin! He is a fierce fighter! Go Odin! Siggy w.gif 21:54, November 24, 2012 (UTC)
  • Derian IS A TANK! Odin is ok but when it comes to a fight, DERIAN IS A TANK!? TheLastLastDragonlord (talk) 10:58, November 25, 2012 (UTC)
  • I voted for Derian. He is MASSIVE. Even though Arthur was able to defeat him I don't think many other people could. ? (I don't know how to sign, sorry(Hidden_Magic))
  • Derian. He stood a chance against Arthur while Odin did not. He is a beast. Maybe if Derian wasn't a giant, Odin would, but sorry Odin, Derian it is! Daniel's signing.pngink=User:Dryuuu 01:00, November 30, 2012 (UTC)Dryuuu

Fight #39b: The Euchdag vs Queen Mab

Victor: Mab (250 votes)

Loser: Euchdag (230 votes)


  • Definitely Queen Mab. Euchdag is a weirdo that can only hide. Queen Mab is a pxie that has an enchanted forest in her possession. MorganaMorgana Pendragon.pngForever19:29,11/23/2012
  • Had to go with Mab. She cool! Euchdag has a big brain!?

Superman-Logo-Signature-QaYYum.png ~TomWelling~ Superman-Logo-Signature-QaYYum.png

04:37, November 24, 2012 (UTC)

  • Haha Chris. They're both completely superfluous characters that have made little impact on the storyline but I think I'm gonna go with the Euchdag! Because she reminds me of one of my favourite movies, ET! GLLC.png Gwaine signature2.pngEquals.pngCenred signature1.png 00:50, November 24, 2012 (UTC)
  • Mab of course! She is a Queen after all! Even Merlin looking at her makes the Euchdag run away, and I never believe she'd actually stand a chance against Mab! Siggy w.gif 21:56, November 24, 2012 (UTC)
  • Euchdag! He know's everything remember!? TheLastLastDragonlord (talk) 10:59, November 25, 2012 (UTC)
  • The Euchdag would probably know what attack is coming and how to evade it... which would be to probably avoid the battle entirely. I'd say Mab, in physical contact! She is the master of a dark realm and would have many more tricks up her sleeve. The Euchdag just runs. :) Daniel's signing.pngink=User:Dryuuu 00:59, November 30, 2012 (UTC)Dryuuu

Fight #39c: Tom vs Elyan

Victor: Elyan (277 votes)

Loser: Tom (201 votes)


  • I think I am going to vote for Tom. As he is after all, whom Elyan learned from. And he has handled with swords for practically everyday since birth! But rest in peace to the two of them! GLLC.png Gwaine signature2.pngEquals.pngCenred signature1.png 02:22, November 24, 2012 (UTC)
  • I vote for Tom. He's my favourite! Sadly, both of them died! Rest in Peace!

Superman-Logo-Signature-QaYYum.png ~TomWelling~ Superman-Logo-Signature-QaYYum.png

04:39, November 24, 2012 (UTC)

  • Easily Elyan. He's a knight for crying out loud! Tom yielded to the knight when he was killed whereas Elyan bravely fought the enchanted sword, and won!
  • Elyan of course! He has been a Knight of Camelot so he has been trained by the King himself. We don't even know how well Tom himself fought, whilst we definitely are aware that Elyan was a very good fighter. So I go with Elyan. Siggy w.gif 21:58, November 24, 2012 (UTC)
  • Elyan. He fought the enchanted sword and helped defeat the immortal army. R.I.P. Elyan R.I.P. Tom? TheLastLastDragonlord (talk) 11:01, November 25, 2012 (UTC)
  • Elyan is a knight of Camelot. In the unlikely case that these two characters would fight, Elyan would probably come out on top unless Tom somehow made his sword snap in half with some blacksmith trickery :) ? Hidden magic ? 11:11, November 25, 2012 (UTC)
  • I voted 4 Tom. He is a awesome father. -Luke
  • Elyan, he's a knight of Camelot. His father on the other hand is dead. Sadly. Sorry Tom. :( Daniel's signing.pngink=User:Dryuuu 01:02, November 30, 2012 (UTC)Dryuuu

Fight #38a: George vs Merlin

Victor: Merlin (506 votes)

Loser: George (54 votes)

  • Now see it depends on the question! George is obviously the more hardworking sevent but Merlin, Merlin is more loyal and would do ANYTHING for Arthur. On the basis of the fact i adore Merlin, its Defo Merlin!! whooop! Emrys!
  • I vote George! Clearly the best and most hard working servant out there. MorganaMorgana Pendragon.pngForever16:47,11/16/2012
  • I vote for Merlin... George made a joke about brass? Seriously... Merlin is more funny than that!

Superman-Logo-Signature-QaYYum.png ~TomWelling~ Superman-Logo-Signature-QaYYum.png

13:24, November 18, 2012 (UTC)

  • Merlin! although George was a great and funny character too, juts he doesn't match Merlin's awesomeness, he just copies. Gwaine artist.png 17:00, November 16, 2012 (UTC)
  • Meeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeerrrrrrrrrrrrrllllllllllllllllliiiiiiiiiiiiiiiinnnnnnnnnnn because is more cool and Arthur prefer him as his servant!!Aithusa poufpouf22 (talk) 17:18, November 16, 2012 (UTC)
  • George! Because otherwise it will be a blow-out... GLLC.png Gwaine signature2.pngEquals.pngCenred signature1.png 03:27, November 17, 2012 (UTC)
  • Merlin is awaesome. Honestly Gwaine is sooo much better
  • I voted for Merlin before I even knew who his opponent was...
  • Merlin has magic, George does not. So unless George somehow manages to bore Merlin to death with his jokes about brass, Merlin will be the supreme ruler of all!!!! Scarletwind"I'm checking for woodworm" 23:03, November 18, 2012 (UTC
  • Merlin of course!!! he could beat George in a fight with his magic and he could beat him in a funny contest (of course anybody could beat a guy who makes jokes about brass) and Arther prefers him as a servant... want to hear a joke? all that glitters is not gold...cus brass does too.. OK i know not funny
  • Actually its interesting because as far as silly scenes go, I really do love George -- but Merlin is just such a wonderful character and there's no way I could pick anyone over Merlin.
  • No offense, but Merlin is a terrible servant, much as everyone loves him. George is so awesome, how could you not like a manservant who makes jokes about brass?! Comment by
  • GEORGE IS THE BEST SERVANT EVER! He would whoop Merlin's butt in a "Clean-off" TheLastLastDragonlord (talk) 19:26, November 20, 2012 (UTC)
  • As a servant, George. As an advisor, companion, protector, and all that.. definitely Merlin. But I would certainly have George in my house as a servant. I just wouldn't talk to him. He scares me ;) Daniel's signing.pngink=User:Dryuuu 13:39, November 21, 2012 (UTC)Dryuuu
  • George because his name is the same as User:GWAINE and he is an awesome servant that should make a comeback! J8in (talk) 03:37, November 22, 2012 (UTC)
  • OK so clearly George is the better servant (Merlin's a better friend - even he admits he's a lousy servant) but since the vote was for favourite servant - my vote is definitely Merlin.

Fight #38b: Fomorroh vs Nathair

Victor: Fomorroh (180 votes)

Loser: Nathair (90 votes)

  • Nathair! It causes more pain and would make the Fomorroh would beg for mercy! MorganaMorgana Pendragon.pngForever16:47,11/16/2012
  • Fommoroh!!! I love them...They could control people's mind! Real cool!

Superman-Logo-Signature-QaYYum.png ~TomWelling~ Superman-Logo-Signature-QaYYum.png

13:25, November 18, 2012 (UTC)

  • Nathair! they cause way much more pain and the formmoroh died, nathair didn't as far as i can remember Gwaine artist.png 16:58, November 16, 2012 (UTC)
  • Nathair looks more evil and more powerful so.......Aithusa poufpouf22 (talk) 17:20, November 16, 2012 (UTC)
  • Nathair! He is better than the fommorroh becasue the fomorroh tortures but also controls minds. Nathair is a nicer character.
  • Fommorroh it seems to be more powerful magicly and it can regrow its heads even when they are not on its body!!
  • Nathair. They casue extreme amount's of pain. Even Elyan gave up to one. TheLastLastDragonlord (talk) 19:27, November 20, 2012 (UTC)
  • Well the Fomorroh would try possessing the Nathair but the Nathair's bite would make the Fomorroh scream for mercy. Whichever is faster to get to the other I guess. I would go with.. Nathair. It's a very tight decision, though. I may even change my mind after this! Daniel's signing.pngink=User:Dryuuu 13:55, November 21, 2012 (UTC)Dryuuu

Fight #37a: The Troll (Catrina) vs Grunhilda

Victor: The Troll (Catrina) (198 votes)

Loser: Grunhilda (57 votes)


  • I voted Catrina because I just found her a more interesting character, even if she was totally disgusting... And it was nice seeing Uther look stupid. :3
  • My vote goes to....The Troll!!! Both were hideous in their true forms, but I found the Troll disgustingly funny. "Your wife is a troll, sir!" MorganaMorgana Pendragon.pngForever19:04,11/9/2012

I vote for Grunhilda, only because she annoyed us for only one episode as oppose to two. GLLC.png Gwaine signature2.pngEquals.pngCenred signature1.png 04:21, November 10, 2012 (UTC)

  • I vote Grunhilda because she is more fun!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!LOLAithusa poufpouf22 (talk) 11:14, November 10, 2012 (UTC)
  • I vote to Catrina the Con-Troll Freak! Cause' she breaks wind...a lot!

~Qayyum1008~ Morgana_moticon1.png

06:07, November 14, 2012 (UTC)

Fight #37b: Cailleach vs Dochraid

Victor: Cailleach (169 votes)

Loser: Dochraid (47 votes)


  • Cailleach! The Dochraid looks like it can barely move, while the other is an all-powerful goddess that even Merlin fears. MorganaMorgana Pendragon.pngForever19:04,11/9/2012
  • I vote for the Dochraid, don't know why.. just did. GLLC.png Gwaine signature2.pngEquals.pngCenred signature1.png 04:21, November 10, 2012 (UTC)
  • The Cailleach for sure... Her "sad eyes" give me the creeps and the Dochraid seems like...BORING!

~Qayyum1008~ Morgana_moticon1.png

05:50, November 14, 2012 (UTC)
  • i wanted to write dochraid bcause she is seen in the episode with morgana as a witch of wisdom about the old religion and looks sick in the sieries 5 trailer but cailleach is a godess and almight being of great power that controls the gate between the souls of the dead and albion and is believed to be even stronger than the great dragon86.169.180.96 18:32, November 11, 2012 (UTC)

Fight #36a: Aredian vs The Gleeman

Victor: Aredian (160 votes)

Loser: The Gleeman (41 votes)


  • Aredian. He was one of my favorite guest stars and antagonists. He was also really smart and instantly found out all of Camelot's sorcerers at once. The Gleeman was one of my least favorites, on the otherh and. MorganaMorgana Pendragon.pngForever19:12,11/2/2012
  • Tough decision in terms of who's a better fighter so I'm going to go with which villain was better. And with the complete opinion of myself, it's Aredian! He was a villain that we could all be scared of. Charles Dance did an outstanding job in playing him! GLLC.png Gwaine signature2.pngEquals.pngCenred signature1.png 02:31, November 3, 2012 (UTC)
  • The Gleeman, based off what I've seen. He was trained to do the job. Aredian is not a fighter, he is a con man. Possibly a sorcerer, but I think he mainly relies on his brains. The Gleeman lost to Uther because Uther is a king and he conquered Camelot! (He's also a jerk who deserves to be dead in my opinion) Daniel's signing.pngink=User:Dryuuu 13:19, November 4, 2012 (UTC)Dryuuu
  • Aredian. Freakiest villian EVER! Gleeman was a horrible villian and just beat Uther only because Uther was mad and Arthur was drugged. TheLastLastDragonlord (talk) 15:06, November 4, 2012 (UTC)
  • Aredian. He's more cool than The Gleeman. The Gleeman is a weirdo villain ever! ~~Qayyum1008~~

Fight #36b: Gaius vs Alice

Victor: Gaius (275 votes)

Loser: Alice (25 votes)


  • Alice, obviously. Even Gaius acccepted that she had a natural gift when it came to magic. MorganaMorgana Pendragon.pngForever19:10,11/2/2012
  • Alice, getting sick of Gaius and plus, quite a good sorceress as well she is! GLLC.png Gwaine signature2.pngEquals.pngCenred signature1.png 02:32, November 3, 2012 (UTC)
  • Because Gaius is the best. Gaiusthecourtphysician
  • Had to go for Gaius. We only know that Alice is good at restoration magic we have no idea how good she is in a fight. Giaus has proven to be a good sorcerer when defeating Morgause with Merlin. TheLastLastDragonlord (talk) 17:20, November 3, 2012 (UTC)
  • Gaius. Alice is a healer. Gaius has had more first hand experience in magical duels, despite it being only brief. Alice would have had to hide her secrets but probably didn't fight, as Gaius struck her off the list and she got mine time to get away and would've been forgotten about (considering her age and how many were persecuted during the Purge). Gaius also probably practiced a little before going and striking Morgause in The Coming of Arthur. Besides, men are naturally stronger than women, it's a fact! Daniel's signing.pngink=User:Dryuuu 13:21, November 4, 2012 (UTC)Dryuuu
  • I love Gauis since the first episode of Merlin!! Alice is kinda cool, but I don't like her stupidity on affiliating with the Manticore and tries to kill Uther. ~~Qayyum1008~~

Fight #35a: Iseldir vs Taliesin

Victor: Iseldir (119 votes)

Loser: Taliesin (68 votes)


  • Taliesin it is!!! He was able to return after his death, and has the reputation of a mythical warlock. Iseldir also is too much of a weirdo and a stalker...MorganaMorgana Pendragon.pngForever19:43,10/26/2012
  • I agree with the person above, he came back from the dead, for god's sake. Sapphowako (talk) 23:56, October 26, 2012 (UTC)
  • I vote for Iseldir, mainly because I just get excited when he appears! GLLC.png Gwaine signature2.pngEquals.pngCenred signature1.png 01:02, October 27, 2012 (UTC)
  • I vote for Talisein he came backfrom the DEAD!!!
  • I vote for Iseldir; Taliesin used his magic to return, as he was the greatest Seer of the time, only to pass on a couple messages and lead Merlin to the cave. While these deeds are important, Iseldir is still a stronger man. He takes the attacks, the constant running, everything, in stride, never acting harshly nor showing anyone any sort of meanness; he keeps so to his principles that, I think, in the face of his death he would still pity and show kindness to even Uther, would he still alive. That shows a stronger sense of character, not only from his magic. And the fact that he gives this influence to his people, and that he looks after them and tries to do good to keep them safe, make him my choice, hands down. -IntoTheLight
  • I vote for Iseldir because he truly represents the Druids -- he's peaceful and wise. He demonstrates a sense of kindness and compassion. He also seems to be wise in how one should use their magic. I also likes how he helps Merlin. As for Talisein to be fair he only had one scene to guide Merlin to crystal cave. So there's not much to say about him. Iseldir however, seems to always appear steadfast in his wisdom and will to give guidance that is needed to protect all that is vulnerable to danger.
  • Taliesin for thewin. He is a powerful seer so it would be almost impossible to deeat him if he knows all about the future. Plus we have never seen Iseldir use a sword or magic so his abilities are unkown. TheLastLastDragonlord (talk) 10:37, November 1, 2012 (UTC)TheLastLastDragonlord
  • He is greater than Iseldir as he guards the Crystal Cave!

Fight #35b: Helios vs Cenred

Victor: Helios (68 votes)

Loser: Cenred (49 votes)


  • My answer is obvious! I much prefer the ridiculously strong warlord who could have Arthur for breakfast, rather than the king who got betrayed by his ally and stabbed by his soldier. MorganaMorgana Pendragon.pngForever19:42,10/26/2012
  • Cenred all the way! plus Tom Ellis has the same birthday as me! Gwaine artist.png 20:00, October 26, 2012 (UTC)
  • Look at Cenred's puny arms, go Helios! GLLC.png Gwaine signature2.pngEquals.pngCenred signature1.png 01:03, October 27, 2012 (UTC)
  • Helios- he can get a woman. He has charisma. He isn't afraid to get his hands dirty. Cenred, is just a little monkey. So what, he can match his own man (he beat his immortal soldier in combat). But he can't send Arthur's dribble flying across the room with one hit like Helios can! Daniel's signing.pngink=User:Dryuuu
  • 12:32, October 27, 2012 (UTC)Dryuuu
  • i voted for helios, i think cenred is cooler but i think helios is the better fighter
  • Cenred is better looking :-/
  • I like Helios because he recused Gwen and he was brave. He had throw down -- strong and BA with a sword. Cenred although handsome was somewhat slimey and a little cowardly. However, he was smart he just did not dive into situations. And I sort of felt sorrow for him because Morgause clearly just used and killed him. I thought that was mean because he tried to do everything just to please her.
  • Helios is class! He isn't a coward and could defeat Arthur in combat whilst Cenred enjoyed hiding behind his immortal army, but Cenred's death was WAY better! TheLastLastDragonlord (talk) 10:39, November 1, 2012 (UTC)TheLastLastDragonlord

Fight #34a: Elena vs Vivian

Victor: Alator (240 votes)

Loser: Aglain (125 votes)


  • I have to vote for Alator! Aglain didn't display any magic tricks, and was killed, while Alator would be around Morgana's level when it came to magic. So, Alator for me! MorganaMorgana Pendragon.pngForever18:33,10/19/2012
  • I vote for Aglain, he is a druid chief and I am sure he possesses some fantastic skills! Gwaine signature2.pngEquals.pngCenred signature1.png 23:57, October 19, 2012 (UTC)
  • I don't know! I don't know! This is such a close match...and we don't really know much about either one of them....I suppose I would choose Aglain, because he has less's very close though. ~~Emily Windsnap~~
  • Aglain can summon serkets! Even Muhlin couldn't fend off serkets! 'Nuff said! ~~St. Moritz
  • Alator, only just! He is more agressive in combat! - Olivia
  • I'm voting for Alator because he's a high priest. He is obviously very skilled and would win instantly-Emmie
  • I'm not very sure why, but I voted Aglain v.v ~Steffy13~ 16:37, October 20, 2012 (UTC)
  • Now this is a tough one, Aglain is a Druid chief who can summon an army of Serkets, but I picked Alator, because we've seen him in action, he kicked Morgana's ass. And he's a Catha, a professional torturer. He's like a Sith Lord, only without the red lightsaber. --MrThermomanPreacher (talk) 14:35, October 21, 2012 (UTC)
  • alator looks like my angry english teacher. i vote aglain Kelbol (talk) 10:27, October 23, 2012 (UTC)

Fight #34b: Alvarr vs Ruadan

Victor: Alvarr (159 votes)

Loser: Ruadan (146 votes)


  • Of course Ruadan! He is such a skilled fighter with a variety of weapons! Despite his age, he has honour and would never use magic, even when faced with numerous knights of Camelot. Not to mention how much of a loving father he was. GO, RUADAN! MorganaMorgana Pendragon.pngForever18:35,10/19/2012
  • Without doubt I vote for Alvarr! The wonderfully hansome sorcerer that needs to return! T5tess (talk) 23:53, October 19, 2012 (UTC)
  • As much as I like Alvarr I'm going to vote for Ruadan... LOL JKS ALVARR ALL THE WAY! CUMMON ALVARR, WIN THIS DUEL! GLLC.png Gwaine signature2.pngEquals.pngCenred signature1.png 23:57, October 19, 2012 (UTC)
  • I will never understand the Alvarr fandom...I'm with Ruadan. I just don't get what's so great about Alvarr... ~~Emily Windsnap~~
  • ALVARR RULES!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! he was there when Morgana turned bad, whereas Ruadan has only been there to help her a little bit.Gwaine artist.png 07:39, October 20, 2012 (UTC)
  • Alvarr of course, he is the best villain of the week this show has ever had! - Olivia
  • I will have to vote for Ruadan. He is much older and wiser and he can definitely be a threat. Even if I like Alvaar, I think he would not win this fight. Merlaa signature name.pngMorgana logo signature.png 08:35, October 21, 2012 (UTC)
  • Ruadan, because he is older and likely more experienced. --MrThermomanPreacher (talk) 14:31, October 21, 2012 (UTC)
  • Ruadan. He is older than Alvarr and has most likely studied the Magical Arts for longer. He was also able to knock out or even kill several Knights of Camelot, even when he was surrounded (at least ten-to-one) and broke his daughter, Sefa, out of the dungeons. Although he didn't escape with his life, he still achieved his goal - to safe Sefa. He would have escaped, but Elyan caught him off-guard. That is why I think Ruadan would win a fight against Alvarr. (Merlin-HarryPotter1)
  • Bandits are more powerful than druids so i vote Alvarr! ~~Tyson~~
  • guys, ruadan is old is a reason which can make him weaker not more wise. i vote alvarr and emily windsnap alvarr is used in EVERY GOOD FANFICTION Kelbol (talk) 10:25, October 23, 2012 (UTC)

Fight #33a: Elena vs Vivian

Winner: Elena (358 votes)

Loser: Vivian (123 votes)


  • I choose Elena, honestly because in real life the actress that plays her, Georgia King, started dating Bradley James (Arthur) when they were shooting that episode and they are still on, so she did win in that aspect
  • I choose Elena! Vivian was too much of a spoiled little princess, but Elena was kind! Not to mention her horse riding skills. MorganaMorgana Pendragon.pngForever19:06,10/12/2012
  • I choose Vivian because she is more beautiful than Elena in my opinion. GWAINE signature name.png GWAINE avatar logo.png 22:32,10/12/2012
  • I vote for Vivian! Only because Olaf was a good fighter and Vivian must've inherited some of his combat skills! And all Godwyn did was hug people, haha! So my vote if for Vivian! GLLC.png Gwaine signature2.pngEquals.pngCenred signature1.png 00:48, October 13, 2012 (UTC)
  • I'd like to pick Elena, but I have to pick Vivian. Her father was overprotective but so was Uther of Morgana. Elena, being possessed by a Sidhe all her life, was relatively clumsy and probably wouldn't be so handy with a sword. I think Olaf would've trained Vivian pretty well, we just didn't see any of it. (Like with Morgana.. wish we did, though) Daniel's signing.pngink=User:Dryuuu 02:55, October 13, 2012 (UTC)Dryuuu
  • I vote for Elena, she's tough and strong, with a good heart! ~~Emily~Windsnap~~
  • I think Elena would win, she seems tougher and smarter, were as Vivian seemed more girly-girl and spoiled
  • I vote for Vivien. She totally seems like a cat-scratching hair-pulling girl fighter to me.... Runehar4416
  • Vivian was spoiled and (honestly) obnoxious; Elena was more of an honest girl and I liked her free spirit! Plus she was definitely not clumsy when not a changeling. -K
  • I voted Elena. The reason is that Elena has righter mind than Vivian. Vivian is till a teenager girl. Mariaforever (talk) 13:39, October 16, 2012 (UTC)

Fight #33b: Tristan vs Julius Borden

Winner: Tristan (263 votes)

Loser: Julius Borden (51 votes)


  • I vote for Julius Borden! He was ruthless and powerful! Tristan was a good fighter, but it seemed he didn't have the courage to stay in Camelot and instead join Alvarr as one of those who have disappeared into oblivion. GLLC.png Gwaine signature2.pngEquals.pngCenred signature1.png 00:48, October 13, 2012 (UTC)
  • Julius had no idea of his intentions. To bring a dragon out of its egg you have to be a dragonlord. He'd be carrying around a big useless egg. And if it did hatch, Aithusa wouldn't listen to him, because he can't speak dragon. We also didn't see his potential with a sword. Tristan was very skilled, handpicked by Arthur to be at his side. I'm surprised he wasn't a knight. Borden may be handy with a crossbow, but I see him more as a coward. So I choose Tristan. Daniel's signing.pngink=User:Dryuuu 02:53, October 13, 2012 (UTC)Dryuuu
  • Definitely Julius! He is one of my favorite antagonists. MorganaMorgana Pendragon.pngForever19:16,10/13/2012
  • tristan becouse we got a better idea of his sword fighting skill

Fight #32a: Morgause vs Morgana

Winner: Morgana (454 votes)

Loser: Morgause (157 votes)


  • It is....Morgana! Although it would be a close match, I believe that series 4 Morgana surpassed Morgause, as the latter taught her all she knew about magic. She is able to use very complex spells in and out of combat, her schemes are more successful, and, what's more, she reached a formidable level of magic power in just 2 years! That's why I vote for the last High Priestess that will ever be. MorganaMorgana Pendragon.pngForever18:09,10/5/2012
  • Morgause has been practicing magic since she was a child so I'm sure she will defeat Morgana who had only been practicing it for a few years! GLLC.png Gwaine signature2.pngEquals.pngCenred signature1.png 01:15, October 6, 2012 (UTC)
  • I think this would be one of the closest matches ever. But Morgause taught Morgana almost everything Morgana knows and I think Morgause would use this to her advantage and be able to win. 123Action
  • This would be a very close match, but I would say that it would be Morgana. gone are the days where Morgana is a mere apprentince, I believe that she is a high priestess in her own right. I think that the determining factor would be Morgana's drive, Morgause lacks her sister's drive to survive. So, if the two were to fight, I'd say Morgana would ultimately win.
  • I think it would be Morgause, considering that she's the one who taught Morgana in the first place...but it would be's like...Obi-Wan vs Anakin in Star Wars III Revenge of the Sith... ~~Emily~Windsnap~~
  • I voted for Morgana. She is not only my most favorite female character, but I also believe that she could win Morgause, if anyone can. She most likely knows all that Morgause can do, and knows about her weaknesses, and can use those to her advantage. Siggy w.gif 09:36, October 9, 2012 (UTC)
  • Morgana. Katie said she surpassed Morgause a while ago, and Morgana has Aithusa who can teach her many secrets and provide her with powers. Plus she was locked away for two years. Daniel's signing.pngink=User:Dryuuu 06:53, October 12, 2012 (UTC)Dryuuu

Fight #32b: Edwin Muirden vs Gilli

Winner: Gilli (248 votes)

Loser: Edwin (136 votes)


  • I vote for...Gilli! Although it would be a close match, Gilli is able to combine magical skills with combat skills, making him a formidable opponent. In addition, although people think Edwin is a more experienced sorcrer, I believe Gilli is equally experienced, but he couldn't use fire spells or wind spells without being noticed, so did not choose to show the full extent of his skills. MorganaMorgana Pendragon.pngForever18:09,10/5/2012
  • I picked Edwin because the magic Gilli's ring conjures is very limited whilst Edwin's magic is much more powerful to a large extent. GLLC.png Gwaine signature2.pngEquals.pngCenred signature1.png 01:17, October 6, 2012 (UTC)
  • Edwin of course! Not only is he one of the best villains ever to appear in the show, but is also a very strong sorcerer. He needs no objects to give him magical powers, while Gilli uses a ring and is powerless without it. Although Gilli is good with the sword, that is of no use against someone as powerful as Edwin. Besides, Edwin is also a much more interesting and complex character: a villain like a villain should be, while Gilli really never was a good villain. And I already choose Edwin because of that! Siggy w.gif 06:58, October 9, 2012 (UTC)
  • Edwin, Gilli sounds like gills and that means he's a fish! Fishes can't beat Edwin! He'd be roast! -Dan

Fight #31: Merlin vs Percival

Winner: Merlin (403 votes)

Loser: Percival (67 votes)


  • I choose Percival! Given that Merlin does not have magic (or else this wouldn't even be a fight in the first place) Percival is by far the strongest! Not to mention his kind personality. goes to the big guy. MorganaMorgana Pendragon.pngForever19:27,9/28/2012
  • I choose Merlin because...Come on...It's Merlin!!! Merlaa signature name.pngMorgana logo signature.png 19:37, September 28, 2012 (UTC)
  • I actually chose Percival over my most favorite character Merlin (which broke my heart a bit). He is my most favorite knight, and I think that he would win this fight if Merlin did not have magic. Percival is very strong and very skilled with the sword. In my opinion, he is most likely the strongest knight of the Round Table. So yeah, go Percival! Siggy w.gif 20:26, September 28, 2012 (UTC)
Percival ASOTM.jpg
  • With the most obvious choice, it's Merlin. He has magic, Percival doesn't. If it was a battle of no magic Percival would clearly take the lead. Due to the fact Merlin does have magic, we already have our winner. EmrysOfAlbion You can't change your destiny 03:19, September 29, 2012 (UTC)
  • I think Merlin will win as he. old defeat Percival just by lifting his hands. Go Merlin! Leonardomerlinfan (talk) 21:16, September 28, 2012 (UTC)
  • Difficult choice, but Merlin probably won't want to use his magic around Percival so Percival will triumph! Sorry Merlin... =/ GLLC.png Gwaine signature2.pngEquals.pngCenred signature1.png 03:47, September 29, 2012 (UTC)
  • I think that Merlin wouldn't use magic because he don't want to learn Arthur that he has magic so...Go Percival! :D Mariaforever (talk) 15:27, September 29, 2012 (UTC)
  • Among the nominees I pick Percival, he is muscular. Connordude (talk) 02:40, October 3, 2012 (UTC)
  • I vote for the warlock fellow. His name says it all. O_0 Tessy771 (talk) 02:55, October 3, 2012 (UTC)
  • Although Percival is pretty awesome...the show was not named after his sheer awesomeness.... ~~Emily~Windsnap~~
  • merlin with magic vs percival with sword=A victory for merlin!

Fight #30: Mordred vs Cornelius Sigan

Winner: Mordred (187 votes)

Loser: Cornelius Sigan (75 votes)


  • I vote for....Mordred! Although it was a very tough choice, Mordred is the one who is foretold to kill Arthur and destroy Camelot, something which Cornelius failed to do...and also we still do not know if Cornelius can put up a fight (he's never used combat spells). So...go Mordred! MorganaMorgana Pendragon.pngForever18:58,9/21/2012
  • Of course I vote for Sigan! He is the greatest sorcerer who has ever lived and Mordred is just a creepy dude. GLLC.png Gwaine signature2.pngEquals.pngCenred signature1.png 23:38, September 21, 2012 (UTC)
  • My vote went to cornelius sigen becuase he is a very powerful sorcerer and he has a lot more experian. Come on he fownd a way to store his soul with all his powers in a stone!!
  • I vote for Mordred because it's not sure that he will always be allied with Morgana. I've heard that he's also sometimes on Arthur's side. Cornelius Sigan on the other hand wanted to destroy Camelot, which is nothing but evil. I also like Mordred quite a lot to be honest. More than Sir Elyan. GO TEAM MORDRED!! TheHydromancer (talk)
  • This is a really tough one. Mordred is winning simply due to popularity- he is a big part of the legend and plays a bigger and better role. Cornelius Sigan is simply an overpowered old spirit who doesn't even have a real body. But his power directly up against Mordred's could deal more of a mighty blow... he was said to be able to even change the tides. By himself, in another body, he managed to bring great terror upon Camelot. But he made a one-off appearance, and was forgotten about after that forever- he seemed more of a gimmick character and an attempt to squeeze in a cool scene at the end where Merlin was persuaded to make a decision whether to be a servant or turn to the dark side. So I now, with hesitation, vote Sigan. Just like Nimueh can probably beat Morgana, Cornelius could beat Mordred, but the latter in both cases are more important. That's my giant justification. Daniel's signing.pngink=User:Dryuuu 10:11, September 23, 2012 (UTC)Dryuuu
  • I voted Cornelius Sigan as he is one of the greatest sorcerors and he would probably be flanked with his powerful gargoyle servants. Also I just like Sigan more than Mordred, I see no advantage for Mordred and Sigan can take over anybody he chooses. Sigan is probably the most powerful foe of Merlin yet and should be treated that way. The Skeleton

Fight #29: Tristan de Bois vs Elyan

Winner: Elyan (201 votes)

Loser: Tristan de Bois (108 votes)


  • I vote for Tristan de Bois, because, you know, he's immortal AND a good swordfighter, so even if Elyan happened to have Excalibur he would still lose...MorganaMorgana Pendragon.pngForever18:47,9/14/2012
  • I vote for Elyan! He's a Knight of the Round Table and I think that says everything! GLLC.png Gwaine signature2.pngEquals.pngCenred signature1.png 02:23, September 15, 2012 (UTC)
    Sir tristan.png
  • I vote for Elyan! Not only is he a Knight of the Round Table but he's Queen Guinevere's brother and King Arthur's brother-in-law. That says it all! Chawk1993 (talk) 08:44, September 15, 2012 (UTC)
  • Once again this is one of those battles where it depends on the weapon. I think Elyan would be a lot better swordsman, because, he hasn't been in a tomb for decades. But Tristan is immortal... so I would vote both, but I have to be a good sport and vote for one- the good guy! (Plus he has purpose to fight- for Camelot. Tristan has no beef with him) Daniel's signing.pngink=User:Dryuuu 09:01, September 16, 2012 (UTC)Dryuuu
  • Elyan is a better warrior, as he has an excellent grasp of staying alive as he manages to get himself into an absurd amount of trouble: poisoned by the Lamia, tortured by Morgana, kidnapped by Cenred, and that's just the stuff I know about. However, none of his escapades are due to ineptitude of sword skills, and they often contribute to his survival. Plus he's generally awesome and I have a soft spot a mile wide for Elyan.
  • I agree with the person above me. Elyan is one tough cookie! If he had a theme song, it would either be the chorus to Survivor by Destiny's Child: "I'm a survivor (What?) / I'm not goin' give up (What?) / I'm not goin' stop (What?) / I'm goin' work harder (What?) / I'm a survivor (What?) / I'm goin'na make it (What?) / I will survive (What?) / Keep on survivin' (What?)" , or the chorus of The Climb by Miley Cyrus: "The struggles I'm facing / The chances I'm taking / Sometimes might knock me down / But no, I'm not breaking". That is why I voted for him. ~ WorshipperOfTheOldReligion
  • I'm not sure I understand the must be talking about some other Elyan--you know, one who's immortal and can kill someone who's already dead...~~Emily Windsnap~~
  • Elyan is truly a survivor, like some of those above me said. I also like Elyan a lot. Long live the Knights of the Round Table! TheHydromancer (talk)
  • i choose Tristan de Bois for because of a few things. one: it says in "excaliber" he was a great warrior right and uther was one of the only people to ever beat him. two: HE'S IMMORTAL!!!!!!! notice the caps
  • I choose Elyan because he appears to be a better swordsman because Tristan de Bois got stabbed quite a lot whenever he fought his opponents despite his immortality while Elyan never got mortally wounded, so if Elyan stabbed him with Excalibur, Tristan would be killed. Broman178
  • Tristan De Bois will just murder elyan. I fail to see how being a knight of the round table can defeat a deadly and near unstoppable wraith.
  • I voted for Elyan. If he had Excalibur, there is no chance that he would lose. He is a skilled knight after all, and has lots of experience with the sword, so I believe in him! Siggy w.gif 17:59, September 21, 2012 (UTC)

Fight #28: Aithusa vs Sidhe Elder

Winner: Aithusa(295 votes)

Loser: Sidhe Elder (108 votes)


  • Aithusa, clearly. She's a dragon. Sidhe Elder lost to Merlin, who is less powerful (as a sorcerer, not a dragonlord) than a dragon. So yeah, vote goes to Aithusa! Morganaforever (talk) 18:21, September 7, 2012 (UTC)
    Aithusa Hatches.jpg
  • Of course my cool Aithusa!!because have healing breath and is an amazing dragon!!!!!!!!!Aithusa poufpouf22 (talk) 18:31, September 7, 2012 (UTC)
  • I vote the Sidhe Elder! He's the elder of the mighty sidhe of Avalon! The rightful winner of this duel! GLLC.png Gwaine signature2.pngEquals.pngCenred signature1.png 12:45, September 13, 2012 (UTC)
  • Merlin took out the Sidhe elder in one blow with his own staff. Merlin has been struck by a Sidhe staff in the past and came out without a scratch (only hearing an odd buzzing noise... meh, here those all the time). So I don't see why a blow of smoke from Aithusa won't take out the Sidhe. Dragons are also quite immortal and probably the most powerful magic beings we've seen on the show. Aithusa it is! Daniel's signing.pngink=User:Dryuuu 03:32, September 8, 2012 (UTC)Dryuuu
    Merlin306 1949.jpg
  • Of course I voted for Aithusa! She is a dragon, and such a small creature like the Sidhe Elder has no chance against her! ฬคtєгฬєςภค 08:37, September 8, 2012 (UTC)
  • Yet another difficult choice for vote but I vote for the wondefully blue mighty Sidhe Elder! I love his colours a whole lot more! And we don't really know enough about Aithusa to make a comment about her defeating another character in a duel. So it's the Sidhe Elder for me. T5tess (talk) 01:42, September 9, 2012 (UTC)
  • Are you telling me....that a little blue bug going to kill a giant, magical dragon???? Yeah, Aithusa's having Barbecue tonight... ~~Emily Windsnap~~

Fight #27: Mordred vs Uther

Victor: Mordred (247 votes)

Loser: Uther (94 votes)


  • I know that Mordred would win this match, without a doubt! Although Uther is a skilled and experienced fighter, Mordred is younger, which means stronger and faster. Not to mention his magic. Morganaforever (talk) 18:33, August 31, 2012 (UTC)
  • Of course, Uther! Despite all the weird things and the bizzar new style of the show, in this case I hope that good will prevail over evil. Before Arthur became Camelot's best fighter, Uther was the champion. He is more experienced and presumably braver in sword fight than Mordred. Mordred relies on his magic more than on fighting skills and his magic will fail due to some unknown reason, like magic always failed in the end when Arthur was in danger during a battle. Let alone that Mordred just has to lose because he is not quite a nice person and attempts to kill Arthur. Uther has to defend and save his son once more. If not on the show, at least in this arena Uther has to win. ;-) Oh and I forgot: Uther is dead, so he fights against Mordred as a ghost. Therefore his age doesn't matter anymore and maybe not even Mordred's magic. Moreover, he can't be more dead than dead. Fimber (talk) 19:24, August 31, 2012 (UTC)
Mordred Arena Image.png
  • I think Mordred would probably win this battle. He's younger and has very powerful magic.
  • Hey..I don't know it's difficult..but i have seen Uther fighting and his good enough but Mordred is younger..I DON'T KNOW!!!!!!!xD(Aithusa_poufpouf22 )
  • Mordred was where my vote went... sorry Uther! You're an epic character... just not the greatest ever fighter... Mordred (in Series 5) will probably be a warrior/knight-trainee and to be by Arthur's side, you can assume he'd be good. ♫ ₪ Ḡwẵine Ḹٍٍkƨ Ĺiĸe Ͼềлȑềd ₪ ♫ 02:38, September 1, 2012 (UTC)
  • Cleerly Mordred. He is a stronger mind and I think it good with a sword now in Season 5. Darkzod (talk) 08:58, September 2, 2012 (UTC)
  • After rewatching the very similarly themed Sorcerer's Shadow episode, it's clear that in this battle, Merlin would secretly help Uther with magic, allowing him to win.
  • Mordred, duh! As much as I loved Anthony Head's protrayal of Uther and all the funny things that happened to him when Uther was still alive, I think Mordred should win this fight.--Chawk1993 (talk) 21:47, September 2, 2012 (UTC)
  • Uther, because he's much more experienced with a sword, and he would have Merlin to back him up against Mordred's magic. --MrThermomanPreacher (talk) 15:38, September 3, 2012 (UTC)
  • Uther is going to die...again...~~Emily Windsnap~~

Fight #26: Guinevere vs Annis

Victor: Guinevere (182 votes)

Loser: Annis (61 votes)


Gwen Vervededa.jpg
  • I choose Queen Annis. I have never seen her fight, so, judging in terms or personality, she is more fierce, strong and independent, and is actually able to run a whole kingdom by herself, now that her husband is dead. She is also logical and does not let her sadness overcome her even when an ordinary human would just give in. Finally, those treats make her far more respectable in my eyes! Morganaforever (talk) 18:33, August 24, 2012 (UTC)
  • I selected Queen Gwen! I just think that because she is younger, she is a lot more fitter and agile. Long live the queen! LokiIsAwesome (talk) 22:49, August 24, 2012 (UTC)
  • I choose Queen Guinevere! Not only is she the rightful Queen of Camelot but she's the love of Arthur's life and the female best friend of Merlin, she is noble, just and caring towards those she cares about and isn't scared to speak her mind. LONG LIVE THE QUEEN!--Chawk1993 (talk) 04:02, August 25, 2012 (UTC)
  • I chose Annis because Gwen is usually very weak against many opponents such as Morgana in the Series 4 finale. ~Merlinarthur~ 08:00, August 25, 2012 (UTC)
  • Hm..why guys is all soo difficult?hey i am joking by the way i vote for my friend Annis because i think she is more good with the sword than my friend Gwen but who knows!!(Aithusa_poufpouf22 )
  • I picked the wonderfully beautiful Guinevere because she is clearly physically and mentally strong. T5tess (talk) 03:22, August 26, 2012 (UTC)
  • Of course I vote for Gwen! She is just awesome at fighting! ♫ ₪ Ḡwẵine Ḹٍٍkƨ Ĺiĸe Ͼềлȑềd ₪ ♫ 02:26, August 28, 2012 (UTC)
  • I voted for Gwen. We know for sure that she can actually fight with the sword, whereas we do not know whether Annis can do that or not. Besides, I like Gwen a lot better. ฬคtєгฬєςภค 20:31, August 28, 2012 (UTC)
  • I chose Gwen because Annis changes her opinions too quickly and she is the widow of a dead king who invaded Camelot despite the peace contract they had for decades. Annis might be an interesting character but she is too fickled in my opinion. Gwen is definitely the kinder and more sensible person, plus she is a good fighter. Fimber (talk) 10:24, August 29, 2012 (UTC)
  • This week it is Annis! She is more experienced, enough said! But that's being realistic, if there did happen to be an episode with a fight between the two, the producers would probably find a way to make Gwen win, just in favour of a better story outcome. Remember Annis lost her husband- if they got in a fight, she'd be driven by her the loss of her husband. She'd think "Why should Arthur have a partner if I can't?". Daniel's signing.pngink=User:Dryuuu 01:36, August 30, 2012 (UTC)Dryuuu

Fight #25: Leon vs Lancelot

Victor: Lancelot (146 votes)

Loser: Leon (116 votes)



  • I selected Leon as he has been a knight longer therefore likely having more experience in combat. LokiIsAwesome (talk) 00:57, August 18, 2012 (UTC)
  • Is difficult but I vote Lancelot I don't really like Leon because his very seemly and I don't really like that and he is better with the sword!!..Hey sorry Leon!!(User:Aithusa_poufpouf22)
  • I chose Lancelot because He has passion and he worked hard to get where he is at. By: (4everMerlin)
  • I chose Sir Lancelot because he has(in my opinion) more skills. I am telling that because he has won Arthur in the past.Mariaforever
  • Lanclot for sure. He was the kindest and most honorouble soul of the whole show. He was much more mature and wiser than the rest of the knights and one of the best fighters, too. Probably the only one who could defeat Arthur in a serious battle. Fimber (talk) 12:52, August 18, 2012 (UTC)
  • I vote for Lancelot because he is more skillful than Leon. GWAINE 12:16, August 19, 2012 (UTC)
  • I chose Leon, because he is probably my favorite knight (having started out as a character only intended for one episode, then brought back because the fans liked him so much, then elevated to the status as one of the original Knights of the Round Table, plus he is one of the characters original to this show (in other words: not from the classic legends)). WorshipperOfTheOldReligion
  • I chose Leon because Lancelot died and corpses don't fight as well as people do . . . :D. Also I just think that the reason Lancelot became a knight was because he had the spirit of one, and because he tricked Arthur. Leon had to have won fairly from Arthur's surpirsed face which indicated that Lancelot was the first person to ever trick him. While Lancelot is a great knight and definately one of the best fighters out there, I just think he relies more on tricks that Leon would be unlikely to fall for. It would be a really interesting battle though, and I think it would be really close.
  • I choose Lancelot! His personality is more fitting for a knight and the same goes for his sword skills. In addition, his sword abilities and personality made him a knight, not his royal blood :) And let's not forget his sacrifice! Morganaforever (talk) 23:17, August 19, 2012 (UTC)
  • I voted for Lancelot! Not only is he the most noble of the knights, but probably also the strongest knight of the Round Table. ฬคtєгฬєςภค 17:59, August 20, 2012 (UTC)
  • I chose Leon because has been fighting for Camolot for a lot longer than Lancelot; therefor would probably have more experience. (User:NCISGirl4Eva)
  • I voted for Leon because he's immortal... ~~Emily Windsnap~~
  • I voted for Lancelot becuase he knows Merlin is a warlock. (I don't know how this relates to anything, but I just like Lancelot better). SuperMarshmallow (talk) 22:22, August 22, 2012 (UTC)
  • Sir Leon has to win this as he has survived so much in the last 4 series. Leon has always been at Arthur's side, and Uther's before that. Plus, even though he did fight for Uther, I believe he supports Arthur's aims far more. Many see Lancelot as great because of his looks- but Sir Leon is rather fantastic too! #Zannie21# 12:02pm, August 23, 2012. Eng.
  • I voted for Leon because Lancelot never asked Merlin how he got arthur to agree to meet him.

Fight #24: Morgause vs Freya

Victor: Morgause (133 votes)

Loser: Freya (132 votes)


Merlin301 2824.jpg
  • I vote for Morgause. I know Freya was Merlin's love interest and she was lovely yeah yeah.. but that doesn't come to help in a duel.. Morgause is a High Priestess of the Old Religion in which should certainly seal the deal of her victory.. LokiIsAwesome (talk) 23:56, August 10, 2012 (UTC)
  • I vote and the 2 xD!!(Aithusa_poufpouf22 )
  • I suppose it depends on when they fought. Pre- or post- Freya's death. But, I had to vote for Freya. Being the Lady of the Lake, and therefore gatekeeper of Avalon, has to count for something! I think that she must have some clout, even over a High Priestess. Merganafan23 (talk) 03:09, August 13, 2012 (UTC)
  • I vote for Morgause. I believe that she is far more experienced in magic than Freya, and, without her Bastet form, she would never stand a chance....It would be interesting to see an afterlife match between the two though! Morganaforever (talk) 08:16, August 13, 2012 (UTC)
    2012-06-15 0834 001.png
  • I chose Morgause. There can't be a question who wins this one, since Morgause is not only a very powerful sorceress, but also a very good swordfighter. Freya's only ability was the ability to turn into a bastet, and now that she can't do that, she really isn't a good enough opponent for Morgause who has has been trained since she was little. ฬคtєгฬєςภค 09:23, August 13, 2012 (UTC)
  • Freya will cream Morgause as she can turn into a Bastet which will maul Morgause. She may be a great sorceror and swordfighter but Freya will destroy Morgause.
  • i pick freya she knows how to turn into animal 0090j (talk) 12:29, August 14, 2012 (UTC)
  • I voted for Morgause as she has the capability of fighting with a sword and magic, as oppose to the Bastet. Morgause should comfortably win. -anonymous
  • I voted for Freya because she was the one who provided Merlin with the solution to defeat Morgause and her immortal army. If you ask me, they already dueled and Freya came out on top.
  • I voted for Freya because despite everything what is meanwhile happening, I still have high hopes that good will win over evil ;-) And Morgause was not a kind person... so, Freya needs to win. Fimber (talk) 11:39, August 17, 2012 (UTC)

Fight #23: Bayard vs Odin

Bayard (111 votes)

Drew with:

Odin (111 votes)


  • I thought about this for a while before eventually coming to a final decision. I voted for Odin because it is possible that his son (who seemed to be very good with a sword) inherited his sword skills from him. LokiIsAwesome (talk) 03:36, August 4, 2012 (UTC)
  • hm..That's difficult..!!I don't know!!!!!!!=\ (User:Aithusa_poufpouf22 )
  • I picked Odin, but only because I like his character better. It is a really tought choice, and since we haven't seen both of them in battle, it is really hard to know how good they are with the sword. ฬคtєгฬєςภค 08:45, August 5, 2012 (UTC)
  • This was really difficult! Ultimately, it came down to the meanings because I know the writers chose character names for a reason. Heres what I know about both names: Bayard- Derived from Old French baiart meaning "bay coloured". In medieval French poetry,
    Bayard was a bay horse owned by Renaud de Montauban and his brothers. The horse could magically adjust its size to carry multiple riders. Odin- Anglicized form of Óðinn, which was derived from óðr, meaning "inspiration, rage, frenzy". It ultimately developed from the early Germanic word Woðanaz. In Norse, Odin was the highest of the gods, presiding over art, war, wisdom and death. He resided in Valhalla, where warriors went after they were slain.(source) I chose Odin. User:WorshipperOfTheOldReligion
  • I chose Bayard because he seemed to be a man of honour whereas Odin is only driven by revenge - and we have alerady had enough people who do the things they do because they seek revenge. Odin was responsible for Uther's death, so I want Bayard to win ;-) Fimber (talk) 16:49, August 5, 2012 (UTC)
  • I pick Bayard because Odin tends to use assassins to do his dirty work for him. --MrThermomanPreacher (talk) 21:52, August 5, 2012 (UTC)
  • I choose Odin. At least he was always honest about his feelings towards Arthur and Camelot, whereas Bayard is an ally but at the same time he craves the throne...Morganaforever (talk) 22:08, August 5, 2012 (UTC)
  • I chose Odin because he seems more mature, self-controled and knows what he's doing which means that he must be a lot more focused in battle. Merlaa (talk) 02:12, August 6, 2012 (UTC)
  • I choose Bayard because he was falsely acquised for a crime he didnt do and before that he truley wanted to make peace with Uther. I did not chooose odin becasue he was a punk for hiring assains and even his knights to try to kill Arthur; one of those times was on Arthur's birthday, but Uther ended up being fatally wounded instead either way its a terrible fate espacially for ones birthday. And also the fact that he wanted Camelot to fall at some point, also if he was so upset why didn't he go and face Arthur or Uther himself , hmmmm.......?By:4evermerlin
  • I chose Bayard, as others have said, because he was one to fight for himself, whereas, Odin hires mercenaries to do his dirty work. By: Merganafan23 16:24:51 Aug. 08, 2012 (UTC)
  • I support Bayard as he appears to be braver than Odin as Odin hired assasins and Bayard was prepared to fight for himself! ~Merlinarthur~ 22:12, August 9, 2012 (UTC)

Fight #22: Gwaine vs Agravaine

Victor: Gwaine (160 votes)

Loser: Agravaine (9 votes)


Gwaine 03 ASOTM.jpg
  • Gwaine... I could write a hundred books explaining why.... sorry Aggie :( LokiIsAwesome (talk) 04:58, July 28, 2012 (UTC)
  • Gwaine of course! Why should I not choose one of my favorite knights over Agravaine? ฬคtєгฬєςภค 11:22, July 28, 2012 (UTC)
  • Gwaineeeeeeeeee!!!!!!!!!!!Is my favorite knights and sure will win!!!!!!!!!!!!(Aithusa_poufpouf22)
  • Gwaine Because it wouldn't be as funny if agravaine was drunk!visitor 14:26, July 29, 2012 (UTC)
  • Ok, I can't even think of a single reason why Agravaine would win! Gwaine is the best knight ever!!! ~~Emily Windsnap~~
  • Gwaine.
    Agravaine 0000.jpg
    Mainly because Agravaine's evil smiles annoy me and Gwaine's smiles are just so joyful that they are contagious. Plus, Gwaine can win a fight when he's out-numbered, unarmed, and either malnourished or drunk and Agravaine is much older and I doubt he could beat Gwaine in a fight. WorshipperOfTheOldReligion
  • Gwaine no doubt, he is just the best. GWAINE  11:53, July 30,2012(UTC)

Fight #21b: Alvarr vs Tauren

Tauren and his cloak.jpg

Victor: Alvarr (82 votes)

Loser: Tauren (12 votes)


  • Without doubt Alvarr will cream! Tauren is a coward, Alvarr isn't. PERIOD! - Loki
  • Tauren for me as he uses the Mage Stone which can even reflect a Sidhe energy blast. Also he would've killed Uther if it wasn't for Morgana.
  • I know it's the unpopular vote, but it seems to me that the logical choice would be Tauren, considering that he uses the mage stone which can reflect even a sidhe blast and he seems to have decent fighting skills. Alvaar just stands around pointing his sword at people and making dramatic speeches about freedom and power. They both have magic, so it's even there....I just don't see where Alvaar has the advantage. :-\ ~~Emily Windsnap~~
  • The Mage Stone can deflect, however it can't deflect if there's nothing to deflect. Alvarr only knows basic magic. However, in combat, he tends to use a sword, and is fairly good with it. So, my vote goes to Alvarr because he would most definitely have this fight under control. And @Emily Windsnap, Tauren does not possess any magic of any kind naturally, the only powers he has are through the Mage Stone with can only deflect energy bolts. Which leaves Alvarr with the upperhand.

Fight #21a: Cenred vs Caerleon

Caerleon s04e07.png

Victor: Cenred (61 votes)

Loser: Caerleon (55 votes)


  • Although I dislike both, I feel I should vote for Cenred. What kind of king abandons his kingdom and just wanders around like a bandit? In addition, I respected Cenred for his combat skills, something that I doubt Caerleon has. Morganaforever (talk) 21:07, July 20, 2012 (UTC)
  • Caerleon: Because he appears to be somewhat more clear-minded than Cenred, which could prove to be Cenred's undoing in the battle.
  • I'de vote for Cenred for the same reasons as morganaforever. Caerleon just up and left his kingdom to go wander the woods like a bandit. Cenred is also younger than Caerleon, thus probably stronger and more agile. ~~Emily Windsnap~~

Fight #20: Valiant vs Percival

Victor: Percival (111 votes)

Loser: Valiant (9 votes)

  • I vote for Percival. To me he seems like a gentle giant. He can be the sweetest guy but have the strongest blow. Only people like that survive in Merlin :) ~KatePaw~
  • I voted for Percival because he is strong and loyal. Valiant is a coward who hides behind a magic shield
Percival ASOTM.jpg
  • I vote for Valiant, because he has a magical shield that can easily kill any opponent!
  • I voted for Percival because he is strong and powerful. Valiant wouldn't even get a chance to use his shield!
  • Percival, as he is bigger and would overpower that brute and his pansy shield!
  • I voted for Percival because of of his gentle nature and his ability to protect his friends from harm. Valiant wouldn't even stand a chance because of his brutal ability to kill his opponents.Chawk1993 (talk) 01:15, July 14, 2012 (UTC)
  • Perce, of course. Valiant is a good swordman, but he cannot resist long without his magic shield. And Percival is stronger and bigger. ~Steffy13~ 09:11, July 14, 2012 (UTC)
  • Percival, because he's a Knight of the Round Table! They don't lose (Only against Merlin^^). WitchOfCamelot
  • I voted for Valiant because he would most likely cheat and Percival, being a Knight of the Round Table, is too true to cheat. Valiant would not only use the shield, but he would find other ways to break the rules of combat, including taking "cheap shots", and would ensure, one dishonest way or another, that he had an unfair advantage. WorshipperOfTheOldReligion 17:29, July 14, 2012. (UTC)
Knight Valiant and the Shield of Living Snakes.png
  • I voted for Valiant because he was the magical shield that allowed him to almost win the tournament with ease, that is, until Merlin discovered it. Lurker in the Woods
  • I voted Percival. He doesn't need sleeves on his chain mail to win. Or a magic sheild.
  • I voted for Percival. He is my favorite knight and besides, I am 100% sure that he is more strong than Valiant and wouldn't need a magical shield to win his battles!ฬคtєгฬєςภค 12:16, July 19, 2012 (UTC)

Fight #19: Morgana vs Guinevere (Rematch)

Victor: Morgana (104 votes)

Loser: Guinevere (44 votes)

  • This match belongs to Morgana. No matter how many times it is repeated, the outcome will not change. I mean, she hasn't practised the sword in years, and therefore defeated the knights of Camelot single-handedly, in one hit!
    Merlin203 0180.PNG
    Not to mention how easily she defeated a blacksmith's daughter, besides being severely injured. Morganaforever 17:36, July 6, 2012 (UTC)
  • I voted for Morgana! There is no question that she would win! Not only has she got magic, but is good at swordfighting as well! ฬคtєгฬєςภค 18:19, July 6, 2012 (UTC)
  • Morgana- while I think Gwen should improve with years of training as Arthur's queen, but Morgana will probably be training fiercely as well, especially after she was stabbed by the knight back in Camelot! She doesn't want to be caught off guard like that again! -Loki
  • I support Morgana because in Sword in the Stone she was able to defeat Gwen while fighting with only one hand and she was injured. ~Merlinarthur~ 02:45, July 7, 2012 (UTC)
  • I vote for Morgana because she's a powerful witch and good at swordfighting! ~WitchOfCamelot~
  • Morgana because she is a kick-butt swordswoman who is much better than Gwen and she is a kick-butt witch WAY better than Gwen. She is the victor unless Gwen has help, and that's not allowed in the arena! -Aithusa07
  • Morgana: She previously easily beat Gwen and allegedly bested Arthur before. Also, her magical abilities rivals those of Merlin and (potentionally) Mordred's. With Gwen knowing the basics of swordwielding and Morgana having commendable abilities in swordfighting and magic, no doubt Morgana will come out of the battle victorious! A Lurker in the Woods
  • I still think Morgana would win. She has magic on her side and she is also very skilled with a sword. ~Steffy13~ 21:18, July 11, 2012 (UTC)

Fight #18: Sophia vs Freya

Victor: Freya (137 votes)

Loser: Sophia (22 votes)

  • I vote Freya because she is Merlin's love. She doesn't need any special powers, she has Merlin :P. ~KatePaw~
  • I vote for Sophia of Tir Mor all the way! She has a staff that blasts away her opponents and what's more she can enchant men to fight for her. Besides, Freya has only fought with the Bastet inside her, so we don't know if she has any combat abilities. Morganaforever 20:12, June 29, 2012 (UTC)
  • I vote for Sophia! She has magic, and Freya doesn't! Without being able to change into a bastet, Freya will surely lose! And even as a bastet she wouldn't be able to win Sophia!
  • Oh, Freya of course! She's a druid, therefore it can be pretty much assumed that she does possess magic abilities as well as being able to turn into a Bastet who could totally claw Sophia apart! She also spent several days inside a cage without any food and was still able to run for her life, to say that her endurance is pretty high. Scarletwind"I'm checking for woodworm" 21:22, June 30, 2012 (UTC)
  • I vote for Sophia because if she came from Avalon, she must be powerful, right? - Lurker in the Woods
  • Freya- Sophia is useless without her staff, and in human form she's uselesss. Freya as the Bastet will claw her apart! She can die in mortal form, you know. -Loki
  • Well, considering that Freya turns into a giant, man eating flying cat....I wouldn't bet on Sophia winning....~~Emily Windsnap~~

Fight #17: Mordred vs Merlin

Victor: Merlin (156 votes)

Loser: Mordred (37 votes)

  • I vote for Merlin! I think Merlin's magic will never fail him. He was born with it and his magic grows stronger everyday. Mordred still has alot to learn so I think he doesn't stand a good chance against Merlin. ~KatePaw~
  • I vote for Mordred, because if somehow Merlin's magic was sealed he would not stand a chance againist a magic-less Mordred! In addition, he displayed tremendous magical skills even a a child. Morganaforever 20:38, June 22, 2012 (UTC)
  • I voted for Merlin! How could I not? He is my most favorite character and I am absolutely sure he would win! ฬคtєгฬєςภค 20:45, June 22, 2012 (UTC)
  • Oh, Merlin all the way! Though he's no knight, he can be handy with a sword when needed and of course, he has his magic. Scarletwind"I'm checking for woodworm" 01:03, June 23, 2012 (UTC)
  • I vote Merlin because he is a great sorcerer and a dragonlord which means he could beat Mordred anyday! ~Merlinarthur~ 03:43, June 23, 2012 (UTC)
  • Merlin of course! He's more experienced, a dragon lord, and destined to untite Albion! I mean, come on face it, he could just call a dragon and have Mordred burnt to a crisp... ~~Emily Windsnap~~
  • I vote for Merlin, because he's older and wiser than Mordred. Pus he's one of my FAVE characters. He is most likely going to win.~Morgana"s_destiny&doom~
  • I vote for Merlin, because he is older and wiser than Mordred, and is a Dragonlord. Plus he's one of my FAVE characters apart from Gwain & Gwen. ~Merlin'sApprentice~
  • I vote for Merlin because he knows how dangerous Mordred can be and that it is Mordred's destiny to kill Arthur so he would work as hard as he could to defeat Mordred and he is my favourite charactor. merlinno.1fan 4:45, June 27, 2012
  • Mordred, because no one else picked him!
  • I believe that Merlin would win because Arthur is too important for the series to die anytime soon.
  • Mordred because he grew up learning druid magic.

Fight #16: Fisher King vs Gaius

Victor: Gaius (77 votes)

Loser: Fisher King (18 votes)

  • I choose Gaius! Although the Fisher King's abilities have not been explored, Gaius was able to destroy a manticore and achieved to slam down Morgause! He would definitely prevail. Morganaforever 20:04, June 15, 2012 (UTC)
    Fisher king.jpg
  • I vote for Gaius as he showed extraordinary magical ability on many occassions, notably when he defeated Morgause. Also, the power of the Fisher King is still unknown. ~Merlinarthur~ 03:01, June 16, 2012 (UTC)
  • The Fisher King as he has the power to keep himself alive. LokiIsAwesomeLokiIsAwesome
  • The Fisher King had the power to keep himself alive in his castle with Wyvren and who knows what else swarming around for like hundreds of years. Though Gaius is awesome, he admitted that he might've forgotten the Old Religion's magic to destroy the Manticore's box and it was also said above that the Fisher king is immortal. Scarletwind"I'm checking for woodworm" 21:55, June 20, 2012 (UTC)
  • I select Gaius because,in the past,Gaius helped Merlin to learned some magic spelsSonicslash38 16:32, June 22, 2012 (UTC)

Fight #15: Nimueh vs Morgause

Victor: Nimueh (74 v0tes)

Loser: Morgause (53 votes)

  • I go with Morgause. It's clear just how strong she is; even Gaius advised Merlin to not fight her, because if she caught him he would die (The Coming of Arthur). Also, although Nimueh has experience by her side, Morgause has arguably the strongest combat spells that have been seen on the show so far. Morganaforever 21:17, June 8, 2012 (UTC)
  • Morgause's magic is more powerful than Nimueh's- Morgause has also appeared later and achieved more than Nimueh. She made a whole army, tens of thousands of people, immortal- all by herself- she formed a column of fire without a single chant, and she equals Arthur in combat! Morgause!
  • Throughout the series Morgause was able to achieve much more than Nimueh such as launching the attack of the Knights of Medhir, the Immortal Knight, the Undead Skeletons and more! ~Merlinarthur~ 05:37, June 10, 2012 (UTC)
  • I voted for Nimueh. Although I'm pretty sure that are both really powerful, Nimueh still lived for a lot longer and with that comes a lot more experience. ฬคtєгฬєςภค 06:24, June 10, 2012 (UTC)
  • I have to think Morgause would win. If Merlin managed to defeat Nimueh back in Season One when he was still relatively inexperienced, how hard could it be for a powerful witch like Morgause?

Fight #14: Knights of Camelot vs Knights of Medhir

Victors: Knights of Camelot (45 votes)

Losers: Knights of Medhir (27 votes)

  • I choose the Medhir Knights simply because they are unbeatable! They can only be defeated if the witch summoning them is defeated or cancels the attack. So even the knights of Camelot have no chance of defeating them! Morganaforever 20:01, June 1, 2012 (UTC)
  • Obviously the Knights of Medhir would win, as only magic can defeat them, and no Knight in Camelot has magic. Tommy2215 20:18, June 1, 2012 (UTC)
  • The Knights of Camelot, because of their formidable sword skills! If they can outwit the Immortal army, the Medhir knights should be a walk in the park!
  • Sorry Camelot but I have to go with the Knights of Medhir as they can't be beaten! I think that pretty much sums it up! ~Merlinarthur~ 00:07, June 3, 2012 (UTC)
  • I chose the Knights of Camelot. Simply because they have a better cause to fight for. Also, they have some really tough warriors. ฬคtєгฬєςภค 14:10, June 5, 2012 (UTC)
  • In terms of tactic and skill the Knights of Camelot will no doubt prevail. They're the best in the land. Especially the Knights of the Round Table. But.. in terms of mortality, the Knights of Medhir would fall, but they would just keep rising. (Cheaters!) It's sort of a bit of both, but I'll vote one- the Knights of Camelot! LokiIsAwesome 00:36, June 7, 2012 (UTC)LokiIsAwesome

Fight #13: Percival vs Elyan

Victor: Percival (49 votes)

Loser: Elyan (25 votes)

  • I vote for Elyan. He's the son of the blacksmith and although he is not as strong as Percival, he is definitely more agile! Also, he has more backstory than Percival and his character is somewhat more developed. Morganaforever 20:48, May 25, 2012 (UTC)
  • I vote for Percival! How could I not vote for my favorite knight! Besides, Percival is really strong as we already saw when he first appeared! Elyan would most definitely lose! ฬคtєгฬєςภค 21:11, May 25, 2012 (UTC)
  • Percival, because he was with Lancelot who probably helped train him! Lancelot can match Arthur... Elyan can't.. we don't know if Percival can yet, I'm not sure we'll ever find out, but you never know! However we find out, though, it better not be a Lamia 2 that possessed him to fight Arthur.. so I think Percival would beat Elyan. He's bigger and stronger, despite less backstory, which should hopefully be fixed in Series 5. ☾ⓓⓐⓝⓘⓔⓛ☽ 23:22, May 25, 2012 (UTC)Dryuuu
  • I vote for Percival! I mean, the guy's arms won't fit in his sleeves! He is way stronger than Elyan and just as good with a sword. Besides, Percival's way more awesome than Elyan anyway...~~Emily Windsnap~~
    Elyan evil.jpg
  • Just look at the way Elyan fought those Southrons in The Sword in the Stone: Part One, he's just so skillful with a sword and is very athletic. Elyan all the way! XD ♫ ₪Ḡwẵine Ḹٍٍkƨ Ĺiĸe Ͼềлȑềd ₪ ♫ 23:43, May 25, 2012 (UTC)
  • Elyan because he is the blacksmith's son. Spongedroid 04:17, May 26, 2012 (UTC)
  • Without a doubt Percival would win, as although Elyan is good with a sword, Percival is strong and can fight with or without a weapon when in combat. Tommy2215 12:42, May 26, 2012 (UTC)
  • I vote Percival because he is stronger than Elyan.We can see it from his arms(they are so smuggled...)and his height(he is so tall).He can hit him from up there and won._Mariaforever_
  • I vote for Percival because he has the height and strength advantage over Elyan. Also, Elyan and Percival both train under King Arthur, which means their sword fighting skills must be close to equal Merlinarthur 11:25, May 28, 2012 (UTC)

Fight #12: Alvarr vs Lancelot

Victor: Alvarr (100 votes)

Loser: Lancelot (77 votes)

  • I voted for Alvarr because...well I mean, he has magic and he's decent with a sword. ~~Emily Windsnap~~
  • Vlcsnap-2012-05-13-18h46m05s13.png
    As much as I like Alvarr, I am 100% sure Lancelot would not lose this one! Especially if it involved protecting his honor or Guinevere! He has beaten Arthur with the sword, and Arthur has defeated Alvarr so that means that he too could defeat Alvarr. Finally, I like his personality more! Morganaforever 19:42, May 18, 2012 (UTC)
  • Without question I believe Alvarr will win! He has magic. However, if it were sword-by-sword I think Lancelot would have no problem winning. But... Alvarr (HE MUST RETURN!!!!). ♫ ₪Ḡwẵine Ḹٍٍkƨ Ĺiĸe Ͼềлȑềd ₪ ♫ 02:41, May 19, 2012 (UTC)
  • In a fair duel, so sword-by-sword, I'd expect Lancelot to win. He can match Arthur. Arthur can match Alvarr. So I vote Lancelot. ☾ⓓⓐⓝⓘⓔⓛ☽ 02:45, May 19, 2012 (UTC)Dryuuuu
  • Although I want so much to se Alvarr returned Lancelot is much better in sword. GWAINE 11:14, May 19,2012 (UTC)
  • I chose Lancelot because he has a better cause to fight for. And in a duel with swords he would definitely win! ฬคtєгฬєςภค 20:07, May 19, 2012 (UTC)
  • Lancelot2.jpg
    I vote for Lancelot. He was the best Knight of Camelot, and Alvarr is no match for him. ~Steffy13~ 09:30, May 20, 2012 (UTC)
  • I vote for Lancelot because Lancelot beat Arthur and Alvarr was defeated by Arthur, therefore Lancelot is the clear winner :D Merlinarthur 07:11, May 21, 2012 (UTC)
  • How can Lancelot beat Alvarr when Alvarr has magic? Spongedroid 07:41, May 21, 2012 (UTC)
  • Alvarr because hes a wizard. Mellon3 05:46, May 22, 2012 (UTC)
  • Without magic Lancelot but using magic Alvarr so I vote Lancelot XD MorganaEmyrs 20:06, May 22, 2012 (UTC)
  • Spongedroid is right. Alvarr has magic. Cosko-andorra 12:40, May 22, 2012 (UTC)
  • Ummm... Clearly Alvarr! He is hotter! <3 But Santiago is still cute <3 07:29, May 23, 2012 (UTC)
  • Alvarr = alive. Lancelot = does tell u somthing... Darkzod 06:51, May 24, 2012 (UTC)

Fight #11: Mithian vs Guinevere

Victor: Mithian (49 votes)

Loser: Guinevere (45 votes)

  • I vote for Mithian. Yes, Gwen has been shown fighting pretty well with a sword, but Mithian seems to be skilful in severa different weapons. She also has had more practice, and apears to be stronger. ~~Emily Windsnap~~
    411 3.jpg
  • I vote for Mithian. She is probably as good with weaponry as Morgana was, who quite easily beat Gwen. Despite fighting skills, though, you've gotta admire how awesome she is rather than the stereotypical spoilt queens that visit Camelot all the time. She was also the first one to not treat Merlin like a servant! Morganaforever 20:37, May 11, 2012 (UTC)
  • I chose Mithian. Although I actually like Gwen more, I'm 100% sure Mithian would win. She is great with the crossbow! And Gwen can only fight with one weapon, the sword, but she isn't really a skilled swordswoman. ฬคtєгฬєςภค 21:14, May 11, 2012 (UTC)
  • I vote for Gwen! Because you cannot fight with a crossbow in close-combat, so Mithian would be forced to fight with a sword, which Gwen is beast at! ♫ ₪Ḡwẵine Ḹٍٍkƨ Ĺiĸe Ͼềлȑềd ₪ ♫ 00:14, May 12, 2012 (UTC)
  • This is a tricky one, I think Guinevere's abilities would've grown a lot over the years. She is brave and strong-hearted, I mean, she broke into Camelot and conquered it back with the king, what a wicked queen! We don't know how good Mithian's abilities with a blade would be, in close combat with a crossbow she wouldn't really stand much of a chance for that long. Who knows if she's trained in close combat at all, she is a princess after all and that I would consider pretty rare! Gwen has had a father for a blacksmith, she knows a lot about weapons, so I am going to hand it over to Gwen, she needs votes! ☾ⓓⓐⓝⓘⓔⓛ☽ 00:22, May 12, 2012 (UTC)Dryuuu
  • I 100% vote for Mithian because she is a better fighter shown by her skills with the crossbow. Also, Gwen was defeated by Morgana who was injured and fighting with one hand at the time, further displaying her lack of skill.Merlinarthur 01:34, May 12, 2012 (UTC)
  • I vote Mithian because she is more beautiful than Gwen.GWAINE 01:40,May 13,2012 (UTC)
  • Gwen is a warrior Spongedroid 00:16, May 13, 2012 (UTC)
  • I vote for Gwen, since she really loves Arthur and has known him for longer, and shows skill with a sword in "the Moment of Truth". If it was Arthur at stake, she wouldn't stop fighting
  • My vote is for Mithian. She is more skilled than Gwen, and I'm sure she knows to fight with any other weapon.than a crossbow. ~Steffy13~ 19:15, May 14, 2012 (UTC)
  • I vote for Mithian, becuase based on what we have seen from Gwen she's not a very good swordswoman; I mean, she was defeated by an injured Morgana with no magic! So I vote for Mithian.

Fight #10: Isolde vs Tristan

Victor: Isolde (28 votes)

Loser: Tristan (18 votes)

  • I vote for Tristan because he litteraly brought her up so he will know every trick she has and for those who chose her for killing Helios,She STABBED HIM IN THE BACK so it wasnt really a fair fight.
  • S4 E13 Isolde.jpg
    I vote for Isolde, because she has the same sword skills and she's faster, plus she killed Helios... ~~Emily WIndsnap~~
  • This fight is actually the first one that I struggled the end, I chose Isolde, because she has a more interesting character, about same fighting skills with Tristan and is also really brave! She is also kinda cool, talking about wanting a peaceful life in the middle of a battle.Morganaforever 19:34, May 4, 2012 (UTC)
  • I prefer Isolde personality wise but it's a known fact that men are in fact stronger than women, physically. It's the way it is. I would say they are both equal in ability, but whoever can push that to the very limit would be Tristan, coming out the victor. He would defeat her, but would probably be very injured in the process. I do wonder, though, how Tristan fights, or will fight, without Isolde. Maybe if Tristan appears again we shall see! ☾ⓓⓐⓝⓘⓔⓛ☽ 00:21, May 5, 2012 (UTC)Dryuuu
  • Tristan .png
    I chose Isolde because she has a better attitude. When it comes down to who is more skilled I am not quite sure as both showed exceptional skills as swordhandlers. Merlinarthur 00:36, May 5, 2012 (UTC)
  • Isolde killed Helios :( So that means she can beat Tristan. ♫ ₪ Ḡwẵine Ḹٍٍkƨ Ĺiĸe Ͼềлȑềd ₪ ♫ 03:13, May 5, 2012 (UTC)
  • I chose Tristan! I'm more than sure that he would win! ฬคtєгฬєςภค 07:59, May 5, 2012 (UTC)
  • I voted for Isolde, as she was very brave and managed to kill Helios, despite her also being killed afterwards. Also I am a supporter of girl Power :)
  • A difficult choice to make, but I ended up voting for Tristan. Although they could be similar in skills, he has more resilience than her, most of it because he's a man. But I would prefer Isolde as winner. Steffy13 17:36, May 8, 2012 (UTC)

Fight #9: Dragon vs Wyvern

Victor: Dragon (78 votes)

Loser: Wyvern (7 votes)

  • Dragon.jpeg
    I choose the Wyverns. Although I think a Wyvern would lose an one on one battle with a dragon, they have the advantage of the numbers. There are countless Wyverns but only two dragons, and the one cannot even fight yet! Also, the Dragons (at least Kilgharrah) are too cocky and tend to underestimate their opponents, as he did with Merlin, so that can also lead to the Wyverns' victory. Morganaforever 19:02, April 27, 2012 (UTC)
  • I vote for the Dragons as they are larger and more powerful. Merlinarthur 02:11, April 28, 2012 (UTC)
  • I vote Wyverns because they seem to fly a lot faster ♫ ₪ Ḡwẵine Ḹٍٍkƨ Ĺiĸe Ͼềлȑềd ₪ ♫ 02:25, April 28, 2012 (UTC)
  • Wyvern.jpg
    For me it's an obvious choice of the Dragon.. they can breathe fire. Wipe out armies. I reckon one dragon could even take on a bunch of Wyvern. The Dragon may end up dying of injury, though. ☾ⓓⓐⓝⓘⓔⓛ☽ 10:25, April 28, 2012 (UTC)Dryuuu
  • I voted the Dragons. They are bigger and they can also breathe fire.What the wyverns have in flying haste, the dragons balance with size. Steffy13 18:07, April 30, 2012 (UTC)
  • Dragons of course!They're the strongests magical creatures! Mapsal313 20:10, May 4, 2012

Fight #8: Morgana vs Nimueh

{C}Victor: Morgana (83 votes)

Loser: Nimueh (59 votes)


  • I choose Nimueh because she has had decades more experience and the fact that Morgana needs people to assist her all the time like Morgause or Agravaine.Also Nimueh was defeated by Merlin because she was to distracted with sacrificing Gaius,When she actually paid attention to Merlin she blocked his spell and took him down in one hit
  • I choose Morgana because she has more background as a villain, compared to Nimueh. In addition, she is more clever with her actions, thinks quickly, has reasons to fight and I believe she is also stronger magically (although the match would be pretty evenly matched in the beginning)! Morganaforever 19:29, April 20, 2012 (UTC)
  • I chose Morgana as she learnt her skills from Morgause who was a great sorceress. Merlinarthur 00:25, April 21, 2012 (UTC)
  • I vote Nimueh because she is more confident and experienced ♫ ₪ Ḡwẵine Ḹٍٍkƨ Ĺiĸe Ͼềлȑềd ₪ ♫ 01:37, April 21, 2012 (UTC)
  • Morgana I choose, because she actually has real motives... Nimueh tried to kill Arthur, then said she wants Arthur to be king? Morgana has a background we care about, and clear motives. I think Morgause was a lot more powerful than Nimueh, and she trained Morgana to be stronger than her. Now that several years have passed, Morgana would probably be more than a match for Nimueh. Plus, if you put a poppet under Nimueh's bed, she'd be useless- at least Morgana has skill with a sword, that matches that of the knights of Camelot. I think Nimueh was in a separate group of Priestesses from Morgause, so I think Morgause was a lot more well-trained, even despite being a lot younger (seemingly). Finally, Nimueh has no allies, other than undead shades she resurrects- Morgana can much more easily find allies, like Helios, Alator (temporarily) and now, Mordred. ☾ⓓⓐⓝⓘⓔⓛ☽ 01:47, April 21, 2012 (UTC)Dryuuu
  • Merlin vs Nimueh 3.png
    I vote for Nimueh because she's more powerful and more experienced. ~~Emily Windsnap~~
  • I vote for Nimueh because she a 'High Priestess of the Old Religion' of which means she's far greater
  • I vote for Nimueh because she "mastered control of the elements"
  • I vote for Nimueh because she has the "power of life and death"
  • I voted for Morgana. I'm so sad that Nimueh didn't make it past Series 1, since a battle between her and Morgana would've been absolutely epic! Although Nimueh has much more experience, I'm still sure Morgana would win because besides magic she also has swordfighting skills, but Nimueh doesn't! ฬคtєгฬєςภค 17:06, April 24, 2012 (UTC)

Fight #7: Sir Leon vs Helios

Victor: Sir Leon (63 votes)

Loser: Helios (25 votes)


  • I vote Helios due to his defeat against Arthur Pendragon, and I'm sure Leon will run home crying! (that is if
    300px-Sir Leon14.jpg
    he survives, but hey! it's Leon, the survivor!) ♫ ₪ Ḡwẵine Ḹٍٍkƨ Ĺiĸe Ͼềлȑềd ₪ ♫ 10:37, April 15, 2012 (UTC)
  • Without a doubt it is Arthur. You've seen how Helios threw a knight through the air in part one of the finale, and grabbed another one's hand as he thrusted the sword at him, blocked the blow, then slashed him through the abdomen? Helios is matched only by Arthur, who challenged him one-handed, and was beaten. ☾ⓓⓐⓝⓘⓔⓛ☽ 10:46, April 15, 2012 (UTC)Dryuuu
    300px-Helios the Sword in the Stone.jpg
  • Leon is invincible(literally) so go SIR LEON! Merlinarthur 14:02, April 15, 2012 (UTC)
  • Helios is not even a match for Arthur, much more for a knight of his! Helios would dominate anyone in combat! Morganaforever 19:55, April 16, 2012 (UTC)
  • I vote for Leon because he's immortal. ~~Emily WIndsnap~~

Fight #6: Kilgharrah vs Aithusa

Victor: Kilgharrah (105 votes)

Loser: Aithusa (30 votes)


  • Definately Kilgharrah because he has had more experience in a fight than Aithusa possibly has, look at the way he defeated all those knights easily including Arthur. ~~Broman178~~
  • I choose Aithusa because, although he is not yet strong enough to compete with Kilgharrah, he is the symbol of Albion and tries his best to see good in people, in comparison with the Great Dragon who is selfish and vengeful. Also, he saved Morgana so he must be up to something. I definitely vote for the little guy. Morganaforever 21:10, April 6, 2012 (UTC)
    Merlin413 2993.jpg
  • I chose Kilgharrah because, although he can be like a grumpy old man he has helped Merlin so many times and it rekinds me of the Red Dragon as Kilgharrah and the Britons and the White as Aithusa and the Saxons. The fact that Aithusa healed Morgana kinda made me dislike him for almost betraying Merlin. So I definitley vote for Kilgharrah. CMorgan4ever 00:16, April 7, 2012 (GMT)
  • I voted for Kilgarrah because he's older, wiser, and stronger. I mean, come on, Aithusa is a cute little baby i dragon. ~~Emily Windsnap~~
  • I vote for the white dragon! He is young, which means faster! And he'll be able to outwit the almighty and defeat Kilgharrah in a sneaky way...♫ ₪ Ḡwẵine Ḹٍٍkƨ Ĺiĸe Ͼềлȑềd ₪ ♫ 05:25, April 8, 2012 (UTC)
  • I voted for Kilgarrah because he may want have wanted revenge on Camelot but that was for a reason and seeing as Aithusa saved the evil sorcerer Morgana it is clear that he is up to mischief. Although as Aithusa is the light of the sun he may have hidden powers.
  • I voted for Kilgharrah. He is older and has more experience, so I'm 100% sure he would win. ฬคtєгฬєςภค 08:45, April 8, 2012 (UTC)
  • Kilgharrah.However, I'm not so sure of what would happen if these two fought each other.Mapsal313 15:35, April 8, 2012
  • I support Kilgharrah as he is more knowledgeable, experienced, wise and strong. Merlinarthur 23:59, April 8, 2012 (UTC)
  • It's funny because Kilgharrah isn't even red! ☾ⓓⓐⓝⓘⓔⓛ☽ 08:37, April 9, 2012 (UTC)Dryuuu :P
  • I choose Kilgarrah because A - he is one of my favorite characters and B - because he is much older and much more experience than Aithusa. Of course I seriously doubt that Aithusa is evil. He's what? Two, maybe three months old? That's far to young to be holding him accountable for his actions in saving Morgana. Until I see it, I refuse to believe that he did it with the intention of betraying Merlin, which in a way he can't do, seeing as Merlin is a dragonlord and can have complete control over him if he so wished to enforce his will upon him. All this debate about his loyalties has happened a little too soon for me. :-/
  • I choose The Great Dragon, because he has more experience and is older and wiser than Aithusa. Also, he is larger. ~Steffy13~ 17:13, April 12, 2012 (UTC)
  • Aithusa is adorable. He would bat his little eyelashes and Kilgharrah would melt in a puddle of goo for cuteness overload. Just sayin'. :) MissSophieHolmes
  • I vote Kilgarrah because Aithusa saved Morgana. -GWAINE.

Fight #5: Uther vs Agravaine

Victor: Uther (104 votes)

Loser: Agravaine (23 votes)


  • I vote for Agravaine because Uther is recovering from Morgana's betrayal and Agravaine seems somewhat younger than Uther while Uther has aged a lot.
  • Although he possessed a hateable character, I will definitely vote for Lord Agravaine on this one! Uther killed his beloved sister and brother so it's only fair he wins this one. Also, i think that he is a pretty good swordsman, definitely better than Uther, because he was really confident when about to face Elyan and he was even prepared to face Arthur. Morganaforever 19:49, March 30, 2012 (UTC)
  • I'm personally not a fan of either, but in a fight I would choose Uther. Agravaine doesn't seem to really display any type of honorable sword play, and feeds off of lies and backstabbing. He never really actually does anything on his own accord, Morgana's is his driving source. Uther however has managed to survive this long with sorcerer's trying to kill him? Is this really a brain worker to figure out?
  • Agravaine will win because he has a reason to fight for, which will give him more adreniline! ♫ ₪ Ḡwẵine Ḹٍٍkƨ Ĺiĸe Ͼềлȑềd ₪ ♫ 11:35, March 31, 2012 (UTC)
  • While Uther is a powerful swordsman, well, his abilities would have been reduced greatly along with his psychological state after Morgana betrayed him. So I vote Agravaine. Agravaine would also get the rush of adrenaline, as the user above me has stated, that would give him reason to take down Uther... remember Uther is simply defending what is left of his poor, abused soul. In The Sins of the Father Arthur easily took down Uther due to his anger. If Agravaine were in his shoes, I would expect he'd prevail. It's a shame we didn't see Agravaine in action! But that was most likely the intention- his character will forever be shrouded in mystery. ☾ⓓⓐⓝⓘⓔⓛ☽ 12:00, March 31, 2012 (UTC)Dryuuu
  • I choose Uther. I have never liked Agravaine, and I never will. I'm also sure Uther would win, because he has probably had a lot more training than Agraivaine. ฬคtєгฬєςภค 12:40, March 31, 2012 (UTC)
  • I chose Uther because he was able to kill the Gleeman when he was very weak. Agravaine on the other hand is less experienced. Merlinarthur 01:07, April 1, 2012 (UTC)
  • Agravaine has a lot of weight behind him. So Uther will win!
  • If it was before Uther became depressed then i'd choose him, but he became allot weaker after Morgana's betrayal , even if he didn't forget his sword skill. Agravaine, however, is a detmined, strong warrior who is fuelled by revenge for his sister.
  • I vote for Uther.He has quite a lot experience with the sword, and some good skills too. Mapsal313 14:05, April 3, 2012

Fight #4: Arthur vs Gwaine

Victor:Gwaine (72 votes)

Loser: Arthur (66 votes)

Justyfying your choice

  • I choose Gwaine because Arthur has lost even to less formidable enemies in the past. In addition, Gwaine is a dual wielder with the sword, knows some nice tricks and is more badass! He could even bear with Morgana's challenges and actually prove victorious in all of them, something that I don't know if Arthur or another knight could pull off. Morganaforever 20:48, March 23, 2012 (UTC)
  • I support Arthur as he has fought a range of opponents and has been defeated by few. Also, Arthur trains Gwaine and his other knights so he is probably aware of Gwaine's weaknesses.Merlinarthur 21:37, March 23, 2012 (UTC)
  • Gwaine because he fights for honour. Spongedroid 22:16, March 23, 2012 (UTC)
  • Gwaine because he knows the sword better and he has more tricks than Arthur. ♫ ₪ Ḡwẵine Ḹٍٍkƨ Ĺiĸe Ͼềлȑềd ₪ ♫ 22:41, March 23, 2012 (UTC)
  • Gwaine because...well he's just better at fighting! The thing is, Gwaine has NEVER been defeated by his enemies, and also, yes Arthur would know Gwaine's weaknesses, but I think Gwaine would know Arthur's as well... ~~Emily Windsnap~~
  • I choose Arthur because it is certain he would win. Although Gwaine is a skilled swordfighter and fights well even without a sword, Arthur can fight well with various weapons like the mace, crossbow and of course, the sword, and also fights well blindfolded. Plus as he said himself, he has been trained to kill since birth. ฬคtєгฬєςภค 05:12, March 24, 2012 (UTC)
  • I choose Arthur because although Gwaine's been defeated less times than Arthur, Arthurs fought lots more enemies. He's also reigning champion at sword fighting and was probally trained by the best fighters in the Kingdom.Dragonfire8 17:02, March 25, 2012 (UTC)
  • I choose Gwaine bacause he is my favourite character and in my opinion he is stronger than Arthur GWAINE:24,March 29,2012 (UTC)

Fight #3: Arthur vs Morgana

Victor: Arthur (52 votes)

Loser: Morgana (46 votes)

Justifying your choice

  • I choose Morgana because it's fun whenever Arthur loses to a girl. Seriously though, I think the chances of her beating Arthur are really high, since she easily beat those knights and has also beaten him in the past. Also, she is more calculative and Arthur acts too much on impulse. Morganaforever 21:14, March 16, 2012 (UTC)
    S03e02 arthur 03 1600x1200.jpg
  • I choose Arthur, because, realistically, guys do actually have more physical strength than women- it's a fact. More particularly, Arthur has had many more training sessions than Morgana, who Arthur said supposedly "brushes her hair all day", and Morgana fled the room from Arthur when her magic failed in The Sword in the Stone. Helios was brave enough to face him, while Morgana tried to get away. She is also more prone to surprise attacks, such as when she took a strike from behind from a knight when walking up the hall. Arthur is known to take well to preventing such attacks, such as in The Last Dragonlord, when he stopped the thief in the tavern room.
  • Morgana would beat Arthur, I believe, only under the circumstances that he was injured, or gave her an advantage. ☾ⓓⓐⓝⓘⓔⓛ☽ 01:18, March 17, 2012 (UTC)Dryuuu
  • I choose Arthur because admit it, Merlin is going to be at his side! And even if Merlin is not present, Arthur has a good heart and is smart erhmifhewantstobe. He would find a way to defeat her magic without the advantage. Morgana is to spitful, and has no real allies that are any good. Which will lead her to her end.
  • I choose Morgana. There's no question who would win if these two would get in a fight, especially now that she has become such a powerful sorceress! Plus, I've always liked Morgana more. ฬคtєгฬєςภค 11:24, March 17, 2012 (UTC)
  • Morgana has both magic and swordcraft! Arthur won't even last a second! ♫ ₪ Ḡwẵine Ḹٍٍkƨ Ĺiĸe Ͼềлȑềd ₪ ♫ 13:19, March 17, 2012 (UTC)
  • I chose morgana because she has indeed beaten arthur in the past and easily killed few of arthur's men.
  • I go for Arthur as Morgana relies too much on her magic which means she is probably rusty with a sword. On the other hand Arthur has faith in himself as a warrior and has been defeated by few opponents. Merlinarthur 03:47, March 18, 2012 (UTC)
  • I vote for Arthur because he dedicates more time to training and guys are generally stronger than girls. Also Arthur probably couldn't go all out in the past because he cared for Morgana and his honour wouldn't let him attack a girl. Morgana tends to rely on her magic too much now so she probably hasn't been training her sword fighting skills so she would lose to Arthur.Molin Corgan

Fight #2: Arthur vs Mordred

Victor: Arthur (72 votes)

Loser: Mordred (58 votes)

Justyfying your choice

  • I choose Mordred because it is obvious he would beat Arthur anytime. He has magic! And besides that, if it wasn't for Merlin or someone else, a lot of guys have beaten Arthur and would have killed him. However Arthur's personality is way better and my judgement depends on fighting skills alone. Morganaforever 20:08, March 9, 2012 (UTC)
  • I choose Mordred because he is the strongest of those two. He was able to easily defeat more than one man at a time in The Witch's Quickening, so fighting one man, even if it's the legendary King Arthur, should be a piece of cake! ฬคtєгฬєςภค 20:24, March 9, 2012 (UTC)
  • <I chose Arthur because I believe he is more capable and Mordred is still unexperienced. He also has a better personality and should be the true winner! Merlinarthur 21:10, March 9, 2012 (UTC) *I choose Mordred, since he is capable of using magic, plus the Great Dragon foresaw this fight and he saw Mordred kill Arthur so that proves my point. ♫ ₪ Ḡwẵine Ḹٍٍkƨ Ĺiĸe Ͼềлȑềd ₪ ♫ 03:44, March 10, 2012 (UTC)
  • While I'd like them both to be equal (but I won't vote for both), and I think they should end up killing each other, for instance Mordred strikes down Arthur but Arthur delivers a final blow. Mordred has magic, and magic is more powerful than physical strength. So it'd have to be Mordred. If Mordred's magic was blocked, though, it'd be Arthur. But assuming Mordred will have magic, it will be him, in my books. ☾ⓓⓐⓝⓘⓔⓛ☽ 06:08, March 10, 2012 (UTC)Dryuuu
  • Mordred is probably good with a sword right now so MORDRED! 06:15, March 10, 2012 (UTC) *I voted for Mordred only because I think he will kill Arthur, but Morgana will sacrifice herself to bring him back. ~~Emily Windsnap~~
  • Mordreee-eeed! Coz hes sooo cute and he beat arthur anyytimmme!!!!!!!!1
  • <I vote for Modred.I'ts not that I like him, but Arthur would have been killed a lot time ago, if Merlin didn't help him.Besides, Arthur sometimes really gets on my nerves.Anyway, Modred would easily beat Arthur if Merlin weren't there.User:Mapsal313 18:02, March 11, 2012
  • I think Mordred should win because it says Mordred is destind to kill Arthur. Forestfire3 17:59, March 11, 2012 (UTC)forestfire3Forestfire3 17:59, March 11, 2012 (UTC)
  • Mordred would win because his magic beats Arthur's sword from miles away literally. Without Merlin's help Arthur is dead. Plus, yeah Mordred is destined to kill Arthur. (Aithusa07 March 11, 2012 )
  • King Arthur

    I suppose the arthurian legends don't really count when it comes to this, but they both killed each other in all the stories there is out there. (Arthur with a lance through Mordred's chest and Mordred mortally wounded him in turn,) but here it's just too many differences in the show to really know, isn't it? Therefore, I voted Arthur, because ultimately it is believed that he will return from Avalon. The fact that Mordred has magic in this version doesn't change that. (anonymous arthurian-nerd, 12th of March, 2012)
  • Mordred because he is epic and he is magical Spongedroid 07:18, March 15, 2012 (UTC)
  • I choose Mordred because, although Arthur has amazing sword skills and Mordred barely has any, he has magic. So Mordred should easily be able to overpower Arthur.Dragonfire8 19:19, March 16, 2012 (UTC)

Fight #1: Merlin vs Morgana

Victor: Merlin (130 votes)

Loser: Morgana (46 votes)


  • I choose Merlin because he has a good heart and I believe he is the stronger magician. Morgana is evil, and the good ones should always win! 20:51, March 6, 2012
    Merlin smoke.jpeg
  • I choose Merlin because he has more experience than Morgana. ♫ ₪ Ḡwẵine Ḹٍٍkƨ Ĺiĸe Ͼềлȑềd ₪ ♫ 08:19, March 3, 2012 (UTC)
  • I choose Morgana because I want to balance out the forces! Also, because she almost reached Merlin's level and it is a really short period of time that she can use magic, compared to Merlin. #Morganaforever 08:33, March 3, 2012 (UTC)
  • I choose Merlin because he is definitely the strongest. And I can't choose Morgana instead my most favorite character! ฬคtєгฬєςภค 09:28, March 3, 2012 (UTC)
  • I choose Merlin because not only does he have more experience, but he actually fights for what's right, and wants to make everyone's life a better place, which contrasts with what Morgana actually wants to do. While it's true Morgana does indeed rival Merlin, having reached close to his level in such a short amount of time, and many of us may be over Morgana being knocked out by now, if she defeats him, she'll kill him, and where will Albion go?☾ⓓⓐⓝⓘⓔⓛ☽ 13:35, March 3, 2012 (UTC)Dryuuu
  • I vote Merlin because he has the most experience, and has proven hes not afraid to be violent with his magic when he needs to be. He also thinks about spells and uses his head, not that Morganas dumb, I just think she would be lashing out erratically in rage instead calculating carefully in a fight. Specially if she JUST found out Merlin's powers, she'd be like "I KILL YOU YOU TRAITOR!"
  • I choose Merlin because , unlike Morgana, he's defeated a wide variety of sorcerers and magical creatures. Also Morgana's prefers to enchant objects in her hut rather than harm people in direct combat. Therefore, in a duel Merlin should be able to eventually overpower her. Dragonfire8 21:28, March 3, 2012 (UTC)
  • I choose Merlin because if he can't beat Morgana then there's no point to the whole series. Evil reigns, not a happy ending. But seriously, Merlin should win because he's smarter than her, not scared to get his hands dirty and frankly more powerful despite his only "teacher" being a single book whilst Morgana was taught by a high priestess. I also think Morgana would be scared to death if she knew who he was. Lastly, being destined to be the greatest sorcerer of all time has to count for something.
  • I vote for Merlin as I believe he is more experienced with using magic and has defeated Morgana previously.Merlinarthur 01:49, March 4, 2012 (UTC)
  • I vote for Merlin because he is a dragonlord and he has loads more experience using magic than Morgana. He also has beaten Morgana in a prevoius battle between the two (and he was in his dragoon the great form aswell). 13:06, March 4, 2012 (UTC)
  • Um, Merlin because...WELL HE'S MERLIN, OK? He has to win! du! If he didn't than that would be like, weird. And besides, Merlin more experienced, a dragonlord, the main character, oh, and not to mention that HE'S DESTINED TO SAVE CAMELOT!!! hahaha!~~Emily Windsnap~~
  • I choose Merlin, because he is the Emrys,meaning immortal. He's supposed to save the world and reunited Albion! He's awesome!
  • I go with merlin because well in the legend hes imortal so no competition.
  • I think they both will kill eachother in battle. But Morgana is cool, so GO MORGANA!
  • I chose Morgana because it is always more interesting when the villains win - everyone always expects the heroes to win every single battle, but it's more interesting when it's balanced out. I say Morgana wins this one, but I'm sure Merlin will strike back.


A ladder has been logged from the Results of the previous fights.

Show Ladder (Characters)

P=Played, W=Wins, L=Losses, D=Draws, VF=Votes For, VA=Votes Against, %=Percentage, PTS=Points

Win=3 Points, Draw=1 Point, Loss=0 Points

Note: The ladder is for individual characters only. Species, armies; etc, are not eligible to appear on the ladder.

The Merlin Arena Ladder
1 Merlin 5 5 0 0 1203 204 589.71 15
2 Morgana 8 5 3 0 745 463 160.91 15
3 Alvarr 3 3 0 0 339 234 144.87 9
4 Arthur 4 3 1 0 195 179 108.94 9
5 Gaius 2 2 0 0 352 43 818.60 6
6 Gwaine 2 2 0 0 232 75 323.28 6
7 Aithusa 3 2 1 0 329 216 152.31 6
8 Mordred 5 2 3 0 531 403 121.5 6
9 Mithian 2 2 0 0 54 46 117.39 6
10 Lancelot 3 2 1 0 229 218 105.00 6
11 Morgause 4 1 2 0 351 663 52.94 6
12 Percival 3 2 1 0 227 437 51.96 6
13 Aredian 1 1 0 0 160 41 390.24 3
14 Tristan 2 1 1 0 281 79 365.82 3
15 The Cailleach 1 1 0 0 169 47 359.57 3
16 Kilgharrah 1 1 0 0 105 30 350.00 3
17 The Troll 1 1 0 0 198 57 347.37 3
18 Elena 1 1 0 0 358 123 291.06 3
18 Alator 1 1 0 0 240 125 192.00 3
20 Gilli 1 1 0 0 248 136 182.35 3
21 Iseldir 1 1 0 0 119 68 175.00 3
22 Freya 4 1 3 0 275 167 164.67 3
23 Guinevere 3 1 2 0 271 204 132.84 3
24 Isolde 2 1 1 0 29 23 126.09 3
25 Derian 1 1 0 0 232 209 111.00 3
26 Mab 1 1 0 0 250 230 108.70 3
27 Leon 2 1 1 0 179 171 104.68 3
28 Nimueh 2 1 1 0 133 133 100.00 3
29 Cenred 2 1 1 0 110 113 97.35 3
30 Helios 2 1 1 0 93 112 83.04 3
31 Uther 3 1 2 0 198 278 71.22 3
32 Bayard 1 0 0 1 111 111 100.00 1
33 Odin 2 0 1 1 320 343 93.29 1
34 Ruadan 1 0 1 0 145 157 92.36 0
35 Euchdag 2 0 2 0 234 256 91.40 0
36 Caerleon 1 0 1 0 55 61 90.16 0
37 Tom 1 0 1 0 201 277 72.56 0
38 Taliesin 1 0 1 0 68 119 57.14 0
39 Edwin Muirden 1 0 1 0 136 248 54.84 0
40 Tristan de Bois 1 0 1 0 108 201 53.73 0
41 Aglain 1 0 1 0 125 240 52.08 0
42 Cornelius Sigan 1 0 1 0 75 187 40.11 0
43 Sidhe Elder 1 0 1 0 108 295 36.61 0
44 Vivian 1 0 1 0 61 182 34.36 0
45 Annis 1 0 1 0 61 182 33.52 0
46 Grunhilda 1 0 1 0 57 198 28.79 0
47 Dochraid 2 0 2 1 49 172 28.45 0
48 The Gleeman 1 0 1 0 41 160 25.63 0
49 Fisher King 1 0 1 0 18 77 23.38 0
50 Julius Borden 1 0 1 0 51 263 19.39 0
51 Sophia 1 0 1 0 22 137 16.06 0
52 Tauren 1 0 1 0 12 82 14.63 0
53 Alice 1 0 1 0 25 275 14.29 0
54 Agravaine 2 0 2 0 32 264 12.12 0
55 George 1 0 1 0 54 506 10.67 0
56 Valiant 1 0 1 0 9 111 8.11 0
Show Ladder (Species and Armies)

P=Played, W=Wins, L=Losses, D=Draws, VF=Votes For, VA=Votes Against, %=Percentage, PTS=Points

Win=3 Points, Draw=1 Point, Loss=0 Points

Note: The ladder is for Species, armies, etc. Characters are not eligible to appear on the ladder.
The Merlin Arena Ladder
1 Knights of Camelot 2 2 - - 55 28 196.43 6
2 Dragon 1 1 - - 78 7 1114.29 3
3 Dorocha 1 1 - - 8 1 800.00 3
4 Saxons 2 1 - 1 183 46 397.83 3
5 Fomorroh 1 1 - - 180 90 200 3
6 Knights of Medhir 1 - 1 - 27 45 60 -
7 Nathair 1 - 1 - 90 180 50 -
8 Southrons 1 - 1 - 36 182 19.78 -
9 Questing Beast 1 - 1 - 1 8 12.5 -
10 Wyvern 1 - 1 - 7 78 8.97 -