Forum:Ambiguous lemma

Hi, I think we need to get to some sort of consensus about how to handle ambiguous titles. User:Skittles the hog wanted to move the article Valiant to Valiant by cutting the content of the characters article and pasting it at the one which was the disambiguation page, pointing to the equally named character and episode. I reverted those changes, because this way the articles history is not copied and I believed we should discuss such changes first, as we usually have the titles like that, in cases where they need to be disambiguated. Greetings, &mdash; ochristi (t&middot;c) 21:13, November 29, 2011 (UTC)


 * Changes of this nature have already been put into practice with a number of pages e.g. Merlin. The only reason I copy and pasted on this occasion was to avoid disturbing those who can delete pages. I'm not sure what you intent to discuss as the in-universe article should always take precedence over its out-of-universe counterpart - well, at least to my knowledge. Seeing as you have reverted these changes, it now falls to an admin to move the page in the correct manner, so hopefully one is reading this. If you happen to differ in your opinion, please say so.-- 21:17, November 29, 2011 (UTC)


 * OH, I see. I had the impression there were more lemmas with (character), but most of them are indeed now redirected or deleted. Then at least some would have to be dealt with too:
 * Aithusa (character)
 * somehow Caerleon (character)
 * My only concern was the loss of the history, which might be a violation of creative commons. I am totally fine with the purpose in itself, I just like to keep things consistent. ;) &mdash; ochristi (t&middot;c) 21:32, November 29, 2011 (UTC)