User blog comment:Morganaforever/Is Kilgharrah a good prophet?/@comment-4879894-20121108084123

About Morgana, you got it wrong. Merlin didn't poison her because the Dragon said she was destined to be evil, but because she WAS evil at the moment. If Merlin didn't do it, this would have been the end of Camelot.

About Aithusa, Daniel is right, we don't know much about her (him). We have to wait some developpement. For now, the white Dragon is a complete mystery.

I didn't understand your third point. Beside, I was not disappointed by Kilgharrah, but, in fact, by Merlin. Why did he take so seriously the prophecy ? When the dragon, in series one, told him that Morgana would become evil, he answered that the future wasn't set in stone. And now, what happened ? Mordred is a good boy (Gaius is right), he's devoted to Arthur, why Merlin wants his death ? He wants to kill an innocent boy. Since when a man sentences to death an other man because of what he is going to do and not for what he has done (Suddenly, we are in the terrifying world of Minority Report, or, at least, we're getting back in the kingdom of Uther). For what I saw, Mordred endangers only the relatonship between Merlin and Arhur, he is the first threat to their bromance.

I think that Kilgharrah is doing his job, he's a kind of prophet, but a prophecy is not an oracle.