User blog comment:Morganaforever/Why all this hate?/@comment-187.135.61.63-20140102214724/@comment-5102537-20140107111238

It's not a matter of disagreement but simple social conventions. If you think that stating in public that someone is not talented, has no charisma and doesn't look beautiful is not insulting and not humiliating, I don't know how to explain it to you.

First of all, a person is not a product. A fictional character is, a show or a movie is, a piece of bread, a computer, a car is but certainly, a person isn't. That's the difference. If you complain about how things were done on the show, for example, it's alright. Anyone can complain about the product. However, if you complain about the looks of a person or their skills and charisma, it's personal and it's an insult because you're not complaining about the product but about the person on a personal level.

If people complain about the storylines or certain characters, it's not declaring the writers incompetent, because whether or not someone likes the product, it's not an indicator for talent and skills. Not to mention that calling somebody ugly (or as not being beautiful/handsome) is the most immature insult ever. It's downright childish and insulting, plus it's most of all a mere subjective opinion. Which is why generally, a fight often follows such statements. Aside from the fact that this wiki doesn't support insults, we also don't want a childish fight between users that is about the looks of a person.

As for your comparison to complaining about food in a restaurant, if you do, you do it in private. In case you feel the need to put it on the internet, it's about the product only, not about the person. Only if you call the cook ugly and untalented with lack of charisma, you get personal and have crossed the line.

We actually don't have to discuss it since it should be clear to everyone.

I would suggest that you create an account and talk about what bothers you on a blog or in the forum (without getting personal). However, if you disapprove of the very essence of the show - the retelling-concept - have you even watched it?