User blog comment:Domine./Morgana's torturer... Hypothesis./@comment-4814726-20120726021703

Hmm, an interesting thought. But there's still the fact that its a NEW character. So while Alator is a very high possibility, he doesn't QUITE fit the job description.

Here's who I think could have done it.

King Lot

Rodor

Ragnor

Liam Cunningham

I've seen some people are suggesting Arthur, merlin, or Emrys. For one thing, Merlin and Emrys are the same person. For anothher, from what we've seen of their characters, neither merlin or Arthur are so cruel or IMPRACTICAL to hold Morgana captive for two years and torture her. I say impractical becuz it would be much more effcient, and even kinder to kill her rather torture her in a cell for years. Whoever did is both ruthless, enjoys causing pain, and has some sort antipathy for Morgana, either personally, or simply becuz she is a sorceress.